Home - Editorial - POV - Masthead - Contact The Olive Press

 

Follow Up on the News

Time For Infrastructure

“We’ve looked at property at the corner of routes 28 and 28A but that wasn’t available for purchase,” said Lamont. “Also a site on Upper Boiceville Road and one behind the commercial establishment on the southwest side of Rt. 28, near the Esopus, where the old saw mill was.”
The most likely site at the moment seems to be on the northeast side of 28 across from the 28A intersection, Lamont surmises, situated to take in the main hamlet area in Boiceville as well as the school.
“It’s a fairly substantial building but I better not get locked into a size because this is a
preliminary report- not a facility plan with a bunch of design drawings...yet,” added Lamont, who noted the plant was not scheduled to be built until 2007. “It’ll be about the size of Prattsville’s (plant, now under construction), perhaps a little smaller. It won’t be anywhere near the size of Pine Hill(‘s plant).”
A copy of the entire 3-volume report is available for public review at the town offices in West Shokan, Lamont pointed out, describing it as “pretty formal,” covering how the different service areas were selected and reviewed and what could be done in each as well as containing a lot of useful maps.
“The service area includes the Onteora School and the areas around it and across the street, the residential areas- what’s called Upper Boiceville Road to near Deerfield Road- the entire hamlet,” he noted. “We looked at widening the service area but didn’t find the need and the City doesn’t have the money to do it, anyway. This main area includes the southeast side of Piney Point Road- the side towards the school- and everything between there and Rt.28A on the Esopus side...”
The project is encompassed in the Community Wastewater Management Program (CWMP) managed by the Catskill Watershed Corporation (CWC) through New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP or DEP, for short) funding. It replaces the New Sewerage Treatment Infrastructure Program (NSTIP or NIP, for short) which was also funded by the DEP but administered by the New York State Environmental Facilities Corporation (EFC), an organization which also runs the Upgrade program that was put in charge of the overhaul of the Onteora School’s wastewater system. You may want to jot those initials down for future reference. There’s more to come.
Onteora hasn’t made a determination, as yet, to join the Boiceville community system but a recommendation that they do so is in the report.
“It’s cheaper for the school to go into the community system than it is to do their own system but the Upgrade program had already committed the money,” Lamont observed, speaking about a $1.6 million pledge against the $1.2 million additional cost to include the school in the hamlet’s system. “The Upgrade program is responsible for the operation and maintenance (O&M) of (an upgraded school water system and the City has agreed to give the subsidy to the school even if they go into this community program. So, if the bill to the school is more than the school was paying for its system before it was included in either the upgrade program or the community program, the City picks up the difference.”
Lamont’s report also recommends a subsidy for commercial establishments in Boiceville and he refers to a precedent in the NIP program, which was forged under the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) between NYC and watershed towns and included a $10,000 a year subsidy towards commercial use. The MOA produced a list of 22 watershed communities with no wastewater management program or infrastructure which would be funded to create them. By priority, the first 7 funded by the DEP through the EFC were Hunter, Windham, Fleischmanns, Andes, Roxbury, Phoenica and Prattsville. The next 5 of the 22 in priority order (with Boiceville at number 9, after Bloomville) were eventually funded after the renewal of the 2002 Filtration Avoidance Determination (FAD) that saved NYC big bucks by allowing them to treat water supplies upstate rather than closer to home.
“Going into the community program costs the school nothing but it has a big impact on the O&M fees resulting from the program,” he explained. “That’s because the larger plant is cheaper to run per gallon than a smaller plant and the school will take up a substantial portion of
the wastewater capacity. Including the school and reducing the per gallon cost is of particular interest to the commercial establishments because the program has a subsidy for residential users but not for commercial users.”
Residential users will pay an operational fee of $100 a year per “equivalent dwelling unit.” In other words, a building with 2 apartments would pay $200 annually- a fee to be updated for inflation every 3 years according to the consumer price index- with the balance taken up by the DEP’s O&M residential subsidy.
Commercial properties in the service area, however, will probably be faced with an option, according to the Lamont report’s charts, based on the design standards used to develop the overall flow and estimates of metered water use for each business. Price range runs from about $155 a year “up to $4,000 or $5,000 a year if they’re metered and higher if they’re not,” Lamont said.
“The school’s flow will be quite a bit higher than any other business or institution but that will be subsidized by the Upgrade program, so we’re not worried about them,” Lamont said. “But we’re concerned about the cost to some of the other commercials and that’s why we’ve recommended that the City consider a subsidy. NIP communities that got wastewater treatment plants did receive a $10,000 subsidy for total commercial so there is a possibility of getting that. I think Boiceville particularly needs one like it or greater because of how the formulas are set for
the large flow. That will lead, I think, to an even higher cost per establishment than in some of the other communities. So, to make it all equitable, a commercial subsidy is really almost a necessity. There’s some (businesses) that I just don’t think will make it and it has to be feasible for everybody to really work.”
The program will operate on a basic gravity system but a pump station is also part of the design although its location has yet to be determined. The location of the plant itself is “probably going
to be an issue,” Lamont believes, and he anticipates questions at the public hearing along the lines of “Well, if the City wants it, why can’t they built it and run it themselves like they did for Pine Hill, Margaretville, Grand Gorge or Tannersville?” Or “What happens if we run it as a sewer district and NYC goes bankrupt? How long are the controls going to run? All that stuff,” he predicts.
Lamont is confident that he has answers for most of the questions expected. Like “What becomes of the output?”
“The plant will treat this wastewater to the extent that’s required for either discharge into an intermediate stream that leads to the Esopus or directly into it,” he said. “That’s yet to be determined but it will be ‘highly polished’ and treated wastewater because, in the watershed, you’re required not only to do primary and secondary treatment but also phosphorous removal or, in this case, nitrogen or at least ammonia removal, sand filtration and microfiltration through a bank of membranes. It will be crystal clear and much more clean and polished than it would
normally be outside the watershed.”

Ready For A May 16 Vote
A third write-in candidate, George Haug of Shokan, was announced by Olive Superintendent and Olive Matters founder Berndt Leifeld at an April 23 Olive Democratic Party meeting, to run on the same anti-Large Parcel issue that brought in three Olive candidates last year.
At the current board’s April 18 meeting at Onteora Middle/High School, a budget lower than what was previously recommended was voted in, despite concern from several board members that the further cuts were made without presentations or proper public input.
School board trustee Lev Flournoy, who will not be seeking reelection this year, said he would vote on the budget but felt “uncomfortable with the process.” School board president Dave Patterson assured everyone that the line item cuts were a directive at the last school board meeting and the cuts did not effect education.
Business administrator Victoria McAllen said the additional cuts she came up with totalled $255,000. Reductions were made to unemployment insurance, and health insurance cost estimates was slightly lowered.
The vote was six-to-one, with trustee Herb Rosenfeld, the only no vote, stating the cuts ran too deep.
The most controversial part of the budget consists of dramatic cuts made to special education at a reduction of $355,258. This includes the dropping of five special education teachers, speech/language therapist, teacher of the deaf, four teaching assistants and a part time social worker. The high school cafeteria was filled with concerned parents, special education professionals and Onteora teachers trying to make one last effort to convince the school board that they should reconsider… to no avail. A vote to reinstate a popular Teacher of the Deaf position failed by a four to three vote, with Bernholtz, O’Connor, Patterson and Vanacore voting against.
Trustee Mary Jane Bernholtz explained that if the capital reserve fund receives voter approval, it would eventually take care of repairs and other district needs.
As the budget was approved, members of the audience booed with many then leaving quietly, many wiping away tears.
In other business, the board approved Jeff Hanna as acting superintendent of the district in the absence of Superintendent Justine Winters, effective immediately for approximately thirty days.
Patterson said, “Justine’s health is her primary concern at this point, she spent a few days in the hospital last week and she is home and she is alert and talking to us, she misses us and we all miss her, so lets continue to keep her in our thoughts.”
Winters recently announced that she would be resigning as superintendent in June, due to illness. Hanna was acting assistant superintendent two years ago and also helped fill in for Barbara Boyce in 2005 during her leave of absence. In related news, the board approved $18,000 to hire Dr. Richard Lerer as an educational consultant to help search for a new superintendent (see news brief inside).
Director of the Transportation Department Maureen Stancage resigned effective May 12, stating personal reasons for her departure. Hired last August, she is the third transportation director in three years.
The future of the district committee disbanded and when trustee Vanacore asked why she was told it was in large part due to the board asking its consulting architects for possible restructuring to look at other options already turned down by the committee.
An Olive Matters rally about their new write-in candidate, who did not answer calls from the press before press time, has been set for May 10 at the Olive Library.


Who’ll Be In The New Jail?

The state’s auditors, who came under fire from GOP legislators for meeting with Democrats behind closed doors during their investigation last year, pointed out that deficiencies in several key construction contracts led to delays in the constrction, which then led to rocketing expenses as the project’s overall cost rose from $71.8 million to$100 million and rising.
“There were no incentive or penalty clauses in any of the contracts,” state auditors wrote. “As a result, contractors had no incentive to finish their portion of the project on time and within budget. In fact, some contracts actually provided incentives to delay the project’s completion.”
Furthermore, the legislature failed to look out for rampant doubling-up of costs over the years the project has been underway. And worse were the number of gifts purchased for consultants – and legislators, in some cases — with public money.
New Majority Leader David Donaldson faulted his predecessors for failing to write their contracts for the jail correctly, for establishing strong oversight over the project, and
The jail project was first proposed under then-Legislature Chairman Ward Todd, who left office in June 2003 to become president of the Ulster County Chamber of Commerce. Reports say the cigars in question were a gift to him.
Todd, who was later succeeded by Richard Gerentine as chairman, has also come under fire in recent months for a deal he brokered for a casino in the Route 209 corridor without any public input. There has been growing talk of criminal investigations in that case, as well.
Todd, a former head of the Shandaken Republican Party, did not answer calls for this or other stories about the audit and Donaldson’s call for investigation.
Gerentine said he would not comment on the state audit until the final version is issued while new Legislature Minority Leader Glenn Noonan said the draft of the audit should have remained secret because the information in it, according to his beliefs, could possibly be used against the county in litigation.
Back in January, soon after taking new new position, Donaldson said the county Legislature should begin a probe and issue subpoenas for testimony from the jail’s lead characters, including Todd.
Meanwhile, officials with the state Comptroller’s Office said this week that the early, unauthorized release of the draft audit could undermine furture investigations.
“Those who leak an unfinished audit to the news media usually have some reason to undermine the process, usually because they are pursuing some personal political agenda,” said David Neustadt in a letter to the local press. “Such leaks committed by public officials are unprofessional and often intended to mislead the public.”
State audits are initially issued as draft documents, and local officials are given 30 days to comment before a final version is released. The draft contains a standard request by the state comptroller asking “that to the extent permitted by law the information contained in this document be kept confidential.”


Coalition United... For Now

“The meeting went really well. I told everyone I will take it upon myself to distribute agendas to all Ulster member towns before each meeting,” Cross said. “I’m even getting a scanner in my town office to do it on.”
He said that with all towns represented except for Warwarsing, who couldn’t make it because of a time change announced by Cross at the last minute, and Hardenburgh, whose supervisor has taken his town out of the Coalition for at least the coming year – and who spoke with Cross in a private session after the main meeting in Hurley – the general consensus was that although the Coalition needed improvement, and long-needed executive changes, it was better to stay united than to quit.
“We’re back on track… our strength lies in unity,” Cross said.
As for problems others, including Shultis, brought up about Cross’ having changed the meeting’s time without proper warning several times, the Shandaken supervisor said he was forced to do what he did because of a changing schedule by state Senator John Bonacic, who scheduled a press conference at Belleayre Mountain, in Cross’ home town, at the same time he had originally asked Shultis for use of his office.
“It did get a little confusing,” Cross admitted.
Shultis said that that Rochester supervisor Pam Duke and he actually raised the Benjamin Franklin quote about unity in the meeting, and noted that much of the gathering was focused on keeping Woodstock and Marbletown from leaving the Coalition as Hardenburgh had.
“Their biggest problem, as (Woodstock Supervisor) Jeremy (Wilber) put it, is that there’s been no communication about anything from the executive committee or chairman for years,” Shultis said. “Cross offered to put information on his Town of Shandaken website but then Bert Leifeld (supervisor of the town of Olive) said that wasn’t any good… the Coalition should really have its own website and do its own communicating.”
Leifeld had been a member of the Coalition’s executive committee for years until being named as one of two Ulster County representatives to the less-political Catskill Watershed Corporation last year. His fellow representative, former county legislator and current Chamber of Commerce director Ward Todd, loses his seat this May because only elected representatives can serve on the CWC board, according to its bylaws. Leifeld was replaced by his fellow board-member Bruce LaMonda. His seat, along with all representation at the CWT, comes up for election in May.
The Coalition of Watershed Towns first came to light in the early 1990s after the late state Senator Charles Cook provided seed money to fund a coordinated fight against proposed watershed regulations being put forth by New York City, which has controlled the region’s water supply since being granted such authority by the state in the early 20th century. After the CWT’s efforts resulted in the reaching of a 1997 Memorandum of Agreement between the City and Upstate communities, brokered by Governor Pataki, the CWC was formed to administer upstate regulations and negotiated grant-giving by the city, and the Coalition lived on as a quiet “watchdog” entity run, for nearly a decade now, by Windham town supervisor (and former CWC member) Pat Meehan.
The CWT stayed out of the news until recent years when its Executive Committee elected first to back involvement in the Belleayre Resort battles involving Shandaken, and then more recently, to call for a state legislative amendment removing the word “reservoirs” from its controversial “Large Parcel” legislature of recent years.
Cross said neither issue came up at the recent meeting of town supervisors, with Leifeld saying he’d take the blame for the Coalition’s involvement in the Large Parcel issue and Cross himself sidelining into a defense of the Coalition’s involvement in the Belleayre Resort issue, which came largely at his instigation.
Shultis said that although neither issue was a hot topic at the meeting, the Coalition’s decision to weigh in on each was what brought the idea of the entity’s splintering to a head.
As for Cross’ meeting with Fairbairn, designed to try and bring the renegade long-term supervisor and his town “back into the fold,” the Shandaken supervisor said that his assurances that Meehan would be leaving his chairmanship in December seemed to make a difference.
Fairbairn, for his part, said he was still declining to join for this year, and would see how things shook out for the coming year before making a decision regarding his town’s future relationship with the Coalition.
“I just don’t feel that Pat and the executive committee are fulfilling the demands of their positions at this time,” Fairbairn said. “Some changes are needed, especially in terms of communications.”
The Hardenburgh supervisor faxed over copies of letters he had sent the Coalition over a two year period about his concerns and noted that none had ever been answered, or even read into the entity’s minutes.
“Considering the exclusionary treatment and lack of explanatiuon of the CWT toward some of its membership we are curious if its decisions are truly representative of the majority of its constituency,” Fairbairn wrote this past winter, declining his town’s continuing membership.
Previous letters complained about the Coalition’s partisanship regarding the Belleayre Resort project and refusal to listen to other opinions. They also mentioned that the ongoing New York City-bashing by the Coalition was counterproductive, given that the City was still, and would continue to be, a player in local politics.
“We suggest more direct dialog and communications with your membership. Entities working in concert with each other can negotiate stronger compromises from all parties from which it seeks concessions,” he wrote, outlining a request for information on how the Coalition ever contacted its membership about some of the controversial positions its taken in recent years, including input regarding Gitter’s Belleayre Resort project. “I strongly resent Chairman Meehan’s implication that I do not attend to communications sent to our Town Board. It is ludicrous that Chairman Meehan places the blame for his administrative shortcomings on the organization members.”
Meehan noted at the Coalition’s recent April 17 meeting, when the Town of Halcott also decried his and the organization’s actions, that the problem was that towns had forgotten what the CWT did a dozen years ago.

 


Furry Tourists Of Boiceville

The pups arrived in the area thanks to a rescue operation launched last week by Sarah Muir of the Canine Country Club Boarding Kennels in Saugerties where “Lab Rescue” is based. Rougeux, who was looking for a place to board her own Golden Retrievers during a trip she had planned, heard about the ongoing mission to save dogs from over 200 that were being hoarded by an Ohio woman from Muir and immediately volunteered to provide a temporary foster home for a couple of the puppies.
“I thought it was certainly a worthy cause to help this marvelous woman, Sarah, save these dogs’ lives,” Rougeux smiled. “She arranged all of the details of getting them out of there and I know they picked up some more of the dogs over the weekend.”
The Ohio dogs belonged to a breeder in Oakland Village, near Cleveland, who apparently got a bit carried away when she started collecting them.
“ She wound up with over 200 living in her small house,” explains Sarah Muir with an Irish lilt, adding that the dogs were seized after a court hearing on March 6th. Fortunately for the dogs, Muir is plugged into an underground community of animal lovers connected by the Internet which took note of the dogs’ plight and spread the word. The Ohio woman “had released some herself because she realized she was in trouble and my husband went to Ohio and picked up 18. Then we were waiting to see what would happen. When she wouldn’t release any more, we were so afraid that the judge was going to order them euthanized.”
Acting quickly, volunteers mobilized and soon a van dispatched to the rescue returned with another 46 dogs, including a mother and six 10-day-old pups.
“Then we had a ‘chain gang’ working, trying to get them all in,” Muir said of the rescuers busy processing and cleaning the new arrivals. “Of course, we didn’t have enough room for them all but people kept coming all day long, foster homers and other rescue people. We had to get them all unloaded, feed them and get them into separate places. What a day! When I came in at lunch time, I had 30 phone calls and 69 e-mails- all about the Ohio-Arkansas dogs.”
The “Arkansas dogs” were from another rescue in progress at the same time. The Ohio dogs needed a good cleaning up but were otherwise in excellent health, Muir noted. “They are won-der-ful! Very afraid but coming around nicely. All of the ones we’ve had tested so far have had no heartworm, no Lyme (disease), no ehrlichiosis, no fleas, no worms, so, (the Ohio woman) must have been doing SOMETHING right. So sweet and pretty. Once they get to know somebody, they want to curl up in their pocket. They’re so deserving of families. All told, in the last week we’ve rescued 74 dogs. Nine from Arkansas, 64 from Ohio and one local one. We always leave room for local dogs but they usually come in one-by-one.”
The Arkansas dogs were sadly mistreated and “starved almost to the point of death.” One of them is pictured among the happy Ohio dogs on Lab Rescue’s website at www.caninecountryclubny.com where she hopes to add the story of the rescues within a few days. Sarah explained that they would take in a couple of rescued dogs but would have to turn some away when the kennel was full until her husband, Campbell Muir, turned their garage into a rescue base. Their kennel permit allows them to do all this, she says, because the rescued dogs are covered under the license as personal dogs.
Seven dogs have already found their “forever homes” and two of the 6 youngest pups are spoken for when they’re old enough to leave their mother. There are 8 dogs remaining at the kennel and 13 in temporary foster care. The others have been dispersed to other rescue centers in Connecticut, New Hampshire and Pennsylvania.
“I’ve been getting e-mails from all over the U.S. and Canada,” Muir said. It’s just a great network and community. People have to realize how much we need to rescue these dogs. They’re beaten. They’re starved, neglected. We’ve saved so many from death row- a lot of local dogs, of course, but we also took dogs from a puppy mill in Georgia a few years ago and the case in Sullivan County where they all had been terribly abused. There’s never been this many before but they were only on my property for one day and people started coming; a lot of foster homes and friends. It’s amazing how everyone rallies around from afar and from right in this community. The schools are doing bake sales. Pet Smart wants to do an ‘Adopt-a-thon’ for us. It’s just wonderful!”
Donations to Lab Rescue are helpful in covering operating costs and the show of support from the animal-loving community almost as gratifying as the happiness of the dogs snatched from dire straits. When one little girl from the school gave 67 cents, Sarah found herself with tears in her eyes.
Betty Rougeux, at 657-8707, still has a 5 1⁄2 to 6 month old female, pure black Lab that’s had all of her shots as well as Frontline and Heartguard testing, for those interested in adoption. Others can be inquired about through Sarah at 246-0751 or Kiscolabs@aol.com.
“She’s $200 and you get $100 back when you have a dog spayed or neutered- which is required,” Rougeux said. “That just covers our medical costs for their distemper shots and the tests. It’s totally no profit whatsoever. If anything, we pay out of pocket for their food. There’s a bunch of puppies that will be coming along- including a litter of chocolate Labs we’ll have to keep and care for for 8 weeks.”
You have to be careful, though, because if you have a big heart- like Betty and the Muirs- a Labrador is apt to walk right in.

Meanwhile, Town of Olive Dog Lovers and Volunteers, this week, also launched a campaign to help dogs in need.
The plan is to replace an inadequate 2-dog kennel behind town offices at Davis Park with a 6-dog kennel and the first fund-raiser started on Tuesday when raffle tickets went on sale. One of Hoppy Quick’s famous and coveted chain-saw bears (a three-footer)has been graciously donated by the artist for the drawing at the Olive Day celebration in September. At their April meeting, the Olive Town Board agreed to match the money raised by the volunteers toward the new kennels.
Contact Bev Stein, who is heading up the project, or watch for raffle tables outside of the Boiceville Market or in other local businesses.

 


A Jar Of Olives...

Olive citizens are known for their community volunteering. Pam Walkowiak and May Ann Shepard join Robin Sears and the District PTA in presenting a Free Family Health and Fitness Expo on Saturday, April 29 from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. at the Onteora High School. Screenings, booths and exhibits will benefit both the older and younger members of the school community to develop a healthier lifestyle. Local police will host a bike rodeo and assist parents in setting up official identification records for children in case of an emergency.
Olive citizens are so respected that other towns honor them. Mrs. James “Ernie” Levins has been asked to be the Grand Marshall of West Hurley’s Memorial Day Parade. Ernie, who has served Olive for many years on the Planning Board, was the principal of the West Hurley Elementary School. Her grandchildren, Augie and Chloe, will join her in the lead parade car.
The Onteora Budget vote is looming on the horizon. You can vote at any of the elementary schools from 2 to 9 p.m. on May 16. The proposed budget is at the financial level of a Contingency Budget, the lowest level the State says the District would operate on in the event a higher budget failed. It is deliberately low in response to taxpayer complaints. There are two Board of Education seats up for election. Herb Rosenfeld and Maxine Resnick are running for the seats previously held by Herb Rosenfeld and Lev Flournoy. A budget already at its lowest level and two unopposed candidates encourages an apathetic vote. Why vote when the results are pre-determined? Well, here’s a lesson in Civics. There is a third candidate who has entered the budget process in response to the lackluster budget and unopposed candidates. George Haug, who has attended every Board of Education meeting since I can remember, has decided to run as a write in candidate. George said that he wants Onteora back on track as the educational beacon that he remembers when he and his wife Peggy went there. He wants that for his daughter Bridget and for all the children of the District. He is a write-in candidate. To vote for him, one must pull down (or across) the box atop either candidate and write in his name—George Haug. Since candidates run at large, the two candidates with the most votes will occupy the two seats on the Board of Education.
Today I attended a memorial service for Linda Byer’s mother, Edie Jensen, who passed away last week. The service was held in the Phoenicia Theater to honor Edie for her artistic contributions to theater in set design. The Reverend Darmstadt encouraged friends and neighbors to share stories. Carol Davis listed the long list of productions since 1984 that Edie had worked on. As I looked around the packed theater, I noticed many neighbors from Olive were there to pay tribute to this talented and loving woman. It reminded me how very much we share with our neighbors to the northwest. Town lines and politics blur when arts, sports, and charity are the focus. It’s the way it should be. Skiers and actors transcend the “we and they” of political entities. As we left the theater, I recited Shakespeare’s famous quote, to myself, about how life was a stage and each of us played many parts. Exit stage left, Edith Jensen; you played your part well. Good show! Applause. Applause!
And the rain continues promising brighter days ahead. When I was a child, we sang, “Rain, rain, go away…” but we also ran out into the rain in free abandon and danced in the mud with no regard for mess or decorum. We simply danced because it felt good to dance in the rain. I hope you have enough child left in you to slosh through the mud and dance like no one is watching!