(News
Briefs May 25, 2006)
Suing DEP?
The Town of Olive has decided to sue New York City over its
closure of the “Lemon Squeeze,” Monument Road,
for security reasons four years ago, with supervisor Bert
Leifeld saying he’s doing so even though he and other
town board members think they won’t win such a suit
because they were asked to do so by several members of Olive
Matters, the ad hoc group Leifeld formed several years ago
to fight for rescinding of the Large Parcel law. The attorneys
who will actually pursue the case will likely be hired and
paid for by the individuals seeking the suit. The major complaints
local residents have had stem not only from the inconvenience
of major detorus, but also the way in which DEP officials
have repeatedly promised full explanations for the road’s
closure and then not delivered them. More details will be
discussed and decided on at the next town board meeting in
early June.
Big Holiday
The Onteora School District, with unused snow days on its
hands, will be taking an extra long Memorial Day weekend this
year, with schools to be closed Friday through Tuesday, reopening
on Wednesday, May 31.
A special school board meeting has been called for this Thursday,
with rumors flying that there may be a change of direction
involving the current interim superintendent.
Dr. Peter Ferrara, who came to Onteora from the Ellenville
School District, where he retired unexpectedly two years ago,
two years shy of his retirement, was known for having introduced
gender-segregated classes in a number of grades and disciplines
during his stewardship of the school district there.
Olive Matters
Olive Matters, which meets every Wednesday evening at the
Olive Library, has been continuing to investigate legal and
diplomatic means to resolve the Large Parcel issue once and
for all, ensuring it doesn’t effect local taxes again
by coming up on a county or school level basis, including
continuing work to have its ties to reservoirs removed from
its enabling legislation in Albany. They continue to write
editorials to local publications, including this one, to keep
up contacts with elected representatives and to attend and
monitor public meetings, from the town to county and school
district.
A number of the group’s members have reiterated that
their support of recent write-in school board candidate George
Haug was not politically-motivated, pointing out how Haug
has been known for his wife Peggy’s involvement teaching
Health at the Middle School and High School, as well as daughter
Bridget’s involvement in DECA and school service clubs.
“George did not run to insure that the Large Parcel
was not instituted by
the BOE. George ran to improve things for the District,”
said one member.
Budget Changes?
The Ulster County legislature is mulling a new requirement
that would force up to eight county departments to change
their budget procedures for the coming year, focusing on specific
programs and not just overall departmental requests. The idea,
say legislators, is to stem overall tax hikes and a business-as-usual
means of increasing spending on an overall basis year to year.
Under the new procedures, department supervisors will have
to file spending requests several weeks earlier than in past
budget cycles, with explanations for major changes. The Legislature
- run by Democrats for the first time in a quarter-century
- is trying to cut spending in the wake of a $300 million
budget prepared last fall that raised the property tax levy
38.95 percent, the highest among all counties in the state.
Immediate budget reductions were sought in January when officials
learned a $1.31 million cash flow deficit was forecast.
$1.17 million in cuts were unanimously approved by the legislature
in recent weeks to help offset such rising expenses as the
county’s debt service, union contracts, and health insurance
needs. Other significant expenses are expected for a potential
“massive repair project” at the Golden Hill Health
Care Facility, as well as an additional $20 million needed
to complete the county’s crazy jail project. Legislators
voted 21-11 against asking for state Legislature approval
of a county mortgage tax of 25 cents per $100, which had been
projected to bring in $1 million in new revenues.
The county is currently looking into shifting to a County
Executive form of government, as recommended by its recently-disbanded
Charter Commission, to provide better oversight in the future.
Thirty-two people have applied for the interim job of Ulster
County administrator to date, including current Administrator
Arthur Smith, amid preparations for a referendum on a county
executive form of government expected in the coming year.
Legislature Chairman David Donaldson, D-Kingston, said he
plans to meet with the Legislature’s majority and minority
leaders as early as next week to go over the resumes. The
position, which currently pays $94,713 per year, was advertised
nationally.
Jail Jail…
Further investigations into the various expenditures that
have pushed the new county jail millions over budget and years
behind schedule have revealed that the county paid $13,000
to send sherriff’s deputies and former county majority
leader Ward Todd to jail industry conferences at an oceanfront
luxury resort in Hilton Head, S.C., in 2000, and to Las Vegas
in 2001. Current Democrat Ulster County Legislature Chairman
David Donaldson said the conferences apparently did not help
the county meet its intended goal of opening the new jail
and sheriff’s complex by the original target date of
April 2004.
The Hilton Head Island conference in South Carolina took place
Oct. 15-19, 2000, less than a week before international consulting
firm Bovis Lend Lease was awarded the contract to be the Law
Enforcement Center’s construction manager and included
Todd in a junket of jail officials. The Las Vegas conference,
at the Stratosphere Casino Hotel from May 20-24, 2001, took
place at the same time that county officials in Kingston announced
there would a delay in bidding for project’s construction
jobs until 2002. The trip was authorized by Todd, who has
justified both trips as providing officials with training
to ease the transition to a new jail and helping them develop
a rapport with “players” in the construction process.
Legislator Richard Parete, who now chairs the Legislature’s
Law Enforcement Center Project Committee, said Todd should
pay back money provided for the trip in 2000. Todd, who left
the Legislature in June 2003 to become president of the Ulster
County Chamber of Commerce, defended the conferences as a
way to stay current with jail construction and corrections
procedures but did not say whether he would repay the conference
expenses, as he did the costs for a box of cigars uncovered
in earlier investigations. He did say, however, that he has
asked for detailed information about the conference expenses.
“In the scope of things, I think it’s a pretty
minuscule expense that was clearly necessary at the time,
and in retrospect,” Todd said recently of the expense.
On a national basis, prisons and jails added more than 1,000
inmates each week for a year, putting almost 2.2 million people,
or one in every 136 U.S. residents, behind bars by last summer.
Of particular note in the recent governmental report was the
gain of 33,539 inmates in jails, the largest increase since
1997, researcher Allen J. Beck said. That was a 4.7 percent
growth rate, compared with a 1.6 percent increase in people
held in state and federal prisons. Prisons accounted for about
two-thirds of all inmates, or 1.4 million, while the other
third, nearly 750,000, were in local jails, according to the
Bureau of Justice Statistics.
The jail population, it has been pointed out, is increasingly
unconvicted, the result of Judges proving reluctant to release
people pretrial. The report by the Justice Department agency
found that 62 percent of people in jails have not been convicted.
The states with the highest rates were Louisiana and Georgia,
with more than 1 percent of their populations in prison or
jail. Rounding out the top five were Texas, Mississippi and
Oklahoma. The states with the lowest rates were Maine, Minnesota,
Rhode Island, Vermont and New Hampshire. Men were 10 times
to 11 times more likely than women to be in prison or jail,
but the number of women behind bars was growing at a faster
rate.
The racial makeup of inmates changed little in recent years.
In the 25-29 age group, an estimated 11.9 percent of black
men were in prison or jails, compared with 3.9 percent of
Hispanic males and 1.7 percent of white males.
No Child. Well…
Falling short of requirements under President Bush’s
education law, about 1,750 U.S. schools have been ordered
into radical “restructuring,” subject to mass
firings, closure, state takeover or other moves aimed at wiping
their slates clean. Many are finding resolutions short of
such drastic measures. But there is growing concern that the
number of schools in serious trouble under the No Child Left
Behind law is rising sharply - up 44 percent over the past
year alone - and is expected to swell by thousands in the
next few years.
Schools make the list by falling short in math or reading
for at least five straight years. In perspective, the national
total amounts to 3 percent of roughly 53,000 schools that
get federal poverty aid and face penalties under the No Child
Left Behind law. But that number is expected to grow exponentially
as the government now cracks down on schools that, it turns
out, that have not been including test scores from minority
students… an incidence involving over a quarter of all
in the nation. The Associated Press reported last month that
schools were deliberately not counting the test scores of
nearly 8 million students, mostly minorities, when they measure
progress by racial groups. Those exclusions have made it easier
for schools to meet their yearly goals.
Seven states - California, Georgia, Illinois, Michigan, New
Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania - account for almost 70
percent of all schools ordered to restructure. Eight other
states and the District of Columbia list no schools in critical
trouble. In many cases, their school systems do not have five
straight years of test data, the amount needed to determine
whether an overhaul is required.
It has also been revealed of late that not a single state
will have a highly qualified teacher in every core class this
school year as promised by President Bush’s education
law leading the Education Department to order every state
to explain how it will have 100 percent of its core teachers
qualified - belatedly - in the 2006-07 school year. In the
meantime, Alaska, Delaware, Idaho, Iowa, Minnesota, Montana,
Nebraska, North Carolina and Washington, plus the District
of Columbia and Puerto Rico now face the loss of federal aid
because they didn’t make enough effort to comply on
time, officials said.
Department officials would not say how much aid could be withheld
from states to force compliance.
The 4-year-old No Child Left Behind law says teachers must
have a bachelor’s degree, a state license and proven
competency in every subject they teach by this year. The first
federal order of its kind, it applies to teachers of math,
history and any other core class.
Colorado, Connecticut, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri,
Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Virginia, West Virginia
and Wisconsin have yet to be rated.
Meanwhile, while Congress has said they are now willing to
make the No Child Left Behind law more flexible, the Bush
Administration has told them not to expect a lot of extra
federal money to help pay for any training or other means
of adding flexibility.
Democrats have long complained that the law has not been fully
funded, while Republicans argue that federal spending on education
has increased enough since the law was passed. The House narrowly
passed a 2007 budget recently that calls for cutting federal
spending on education by more than $5 billion, about 7 percent.
A Wired Ulster?
The Ulster County Legislature’s Administrative Services
Committee has announced that they have sent requests for information
to Wireless Internet Service providers to create a County-wide
wireless internet access system. Committee Chairman Brian
Cahill and committee member Robert Parete have proposed this
idea as a key aspect of the recently enacted e-Ulster initiative.
Wireless internet access communities are emerging throughout
the nation, particularly in rural areas like Ulster where
high speed internet access is extremely limited. Cahill said,
“Developing a high speed, affordable, wireless, internet
access infrastructure has proven to be a key economic development
tool. Many companies can not relocate or build in an area
that does not provide what has become a necessary tool for
business.”
Parete states, “As a resident of the Town of Olive,
I can personally express the frustration many residents feel
as a result of not having adequate high speed internet connection
available. In addition, this initiative will facilitate greater
capability and access to create the conditions that allow
businesses to be more competitive. At the same time, this
plan will encourage and expand commerce of all scopes to compete
in the global market.”
The Administrative Services Committee will compile information
and solicit opinions and ideas from local governments and
industry experts to determine the most effective means of
implementing this initiative.
While Ulster County mulls the idea, Andrew Halpern of Tivoli,
president of the company American WiFi, has already launched
an effort to bring wireless Internet service to individual
communities, including his hometown, where a contract has
been sealed. Halpern has also pitched his plan to the Kingston
Mayor James Sottile and the Common Council to bring free limited
wireless Internet service to the city, along with a paid service,
free of advertising or time limits, at $19.95 per month. He
said he would be willing to present his plan to the Ulster
County Legislature. But he said he is prepared to seek approval
from rural municipalities, like Marbletown, to provide the
same service.
Halpern said that if all goes as planned, he could provide
the service to all Ulster County towns within two years. Unlike
major corporations, he said, he does not need to make millions,
so he’s able to provide the service for free or at a
reasonable cost. He just needs permission from local governments
to place antennas on some public buildings, but he said his
plan does not require the use of taxpayer money.
Cahill said that he hopes Halpern is successful in his endeavor,
but said he wants to hear from other companies that could
provide the service. “The purpose of this is to make
sure that we can get everybody access,” he said.
Parete said there is a possibility that the county could place
antennas in rural areas on structures it owns, or somehow
interconnect them with the 911 system.
Republicans in county government are pooh-poohing the idea,
saying the internet is not that important as to use public
tax fnds.
Medicare?
Republican are joining the congressional drive to eliminate
the financial penalty for people who missed the recent deadline
for enrolling in the Medicare drug benefit, the latest sign
of a growing rebellion against President Bush on the issue.
Rep. Nancy Johnson has said she has talked to enough colleagues
to believe such a proposal would pass, probably in the fall,
and plans to introduce legislation to waive the penalty.
“The bottom line is this is a democracy, and the Congress
responds to the people and shapes the program so it’s
good for them,” said Johnson, who heads the House Ways
and Means’ subcommittee on health. “I think it’s
fair and reasonable to eliminate the penalty” for 2006,
the Connecticut Republican told The Associated Press in an
interview.
With the endorsement by one of the program’s leading
supporters, Johnson joins the handful of GOP lawmakers in
the House and Senate who have split publicly with the Bush’s
administration’s position that the enrollment deadline
and late penalty should remain.
The administration has made an exception for people who qualify
for extra help because of their low income.
Under current law, people who wait until December to enroll
would have $2.31 per month added to their monthly premium.
That amount would rise annually to reflect the national average
premium for that particular year.
Johnson said the drive to waive the penalty does not reflect
concerns about a program criticized by Democrats as more beneficial
to drug companies and insurers than to older people and the
disabled.
Democrats pledge to keep pressing to extend the deadline and
waive the penalty for people who sign up over the rest of
the year.
The administration’s latest estimate indicates that
about 6 million beneficiaries remain without prescription
drug coverage. Democrats contend the number is probably closer
to 9 million.
Go, Hinchey!
The government abruptly ended an inquiry into the warrantless
eavesdropping program because the National Security Agency
refused to grant Justice Department lawyers the necessary
security clearance to probe the matter. The way things turned
out, the Justice Department’s Office of Professional
Responsibility, or OPR, sent a fax to Rep. Maurice Hinchey
saying they were closing their inquiry because without clearance
their lawyers cannot examine Justice lawyers’ role in
the program.
“We have been unable to make any meaningful progress
in our investigation because OPR has been denied security
clearances for access to information about the NSA program,”
OPR counsel H. Marshall Jarrett wrote to Hinchey. Hinchey’s
office shared the letter with The Associated Press.
Jarrett wrote that beginning in January, his office has made
a series of requests for the necessary clearances. Those requests
were denied.
“Without these clearances, we cannot investigate this
matter and therefore have closed our investigation,”
wrote Jarrett.
Justice Department spokesman Brian Roehrkasse said the terrorist
surveillance program “has been subject to extensive
oversight both in the executive branch and in Congress from
the time of its inception.” He further noted the OPR’s
mission is not to investigate possible wrongdoing in other
agencies, but to determine if Justice Department lawyers violated
any ethical rules. He declined to comment when asked if the
end of the inquiry meant the agency believed its lawyers had
handled the wiretapping matter ethically.
Hinchey is one of many House Democrats who have been highly
critical of the domestic eavesdropping program first revealed
in December. He said lawmakers would push to find out who
at the NSA denied the Justice Department lawyers security
clearance.
“This administration thinks they can just violate any
law they want, and they’ve created a culture of fear
to try to get away with that. It’s up to us to stand
up to them,” said Hinchey.
And all this on the same day it was revealed that the NSA
had been collecting data on huge numbers of domestic phone
calls in recent year.
Meanwhile, the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee,
Arlen Spector, has accused the White House of a ‘’very
blatant encroachment” on congressional authority, and
said he will hold an oversight hearing into President Bush’s
assertion that he has the power to bypass more than 750 laws
enacted over the past five years.
‘’There is some need for some oversight by Congress
to assert its authority here,” Arlen Specter, Republican
of Pennsylvania, said in an interview. ‘’What’s
the point of having a statute if . . . the president can cherry-pick
what he likes and what he doesn’t like?”
Specter said he plans to hold the hearing in June. He said
he intends to call administration officials to explain and
defend the president’s claims of authority, as well
to invite constitutional scholars to testify on whether Bush
has overstepped the boundaries of his power.
The senator emphasized that his goal is ‘’to bring
some light on the subject.” Legal scholars say that,
when confronted by a president encroaching on their power,
Congress’s options are limited. Lawmakers can call for
hearings or cut the funds of a targeted program to apply political
pressure, or take the more politically charged steps of censure
or impeachment.
Specter’s announcement followed a report that Bush has
quietly challenged provisions in about 1 in 10 of the bills
that he has signed, asserting the authority to ignore more
than 750 statutes. Over the past five years, Bush has stated
that he can defy any statute that conflicts with his interpretation
of the Constitution. In many instances, Bush cited his role
as head of the executive branch or as commander in chief to
justify the exemption.
The statutes that Bush has asserted the right to override
include numerous rules and regulations for the military, job
protections for whistle-blowers who tell Congress about possible
government wrongdoing, affirmative action requirements, and
safeguards against political interference in federally funded
research.
Bush made the claims in ‘’signing statements,”
official documents in which a president lays out his interpretation
of a bill for the executive branch, creating guidelines to
follow when it implements the law. The statements are filed
without fanfare in the federal record, often following ceremonies
in which the president made no mention of the objections he
was about to raise in the bill, even as he signed it into
law.
Dana Perino, a White House spokeswoman, said via e-mail that
if Specter calls a hearing, ‘’by all means we
will ensure he has the information he needs.” She pointed
out that other presidents dating to the 19th century have
‘’on occasion” issued statements that raise
constitutional concerns about provisions in new laws. But
while previous presidents did occasionally challenge provisions
in laws while signing them, legal scholars say, the frequency
and breadth of Bush’s use of that power are unprecedented.
Stay tuned…
Facing Spitzer
Former state Assemblyman John Faso of
Columbia County is talking about capping all school budget
increases to 4 percent a year, no matter the circumstances,
as part of his bid for governor: taxes and jobs, in which
he first faces former Massachusetts governor (and new Delaware
County resident) William Weld before taking on Democratic
candidate Eliot Spitzer in November. He also proposes revising
state rules mandating the number of contractors that must
be hired in school construction projects. He said that if
his proposals were implemented, he would also call for a better
exemption package under the state’s School Tax Relief
program, commonly known as STAR.
Faso, who lost a 2002 bid to become the state comptroller,
said he is in the race to give voters a choice. In the 2002
race, he lost by 3 percentage points to the Democratic victor,
Alan Hevesi.
Bug Season…
They’re back—and they’re hungry! Gypsy moths
and tent caterpillars, two of the most voracious forest pests
in the Northeast, are poised to once again cause serious defoliation
of region’s shade, fruit and ornamental trees. Both
species feed on the leaves of trees commonly found in our
forests and backyards such as oak, elm, ash, cherry, crab
apple and dogwoods. Any trees, particularly conifers, that
suffer from two successive years of defoliation usually don’t
survive so it’s important to be on the look out for
these brutal bugs. Early detection can be the key to preventing
lasting damage.
Eastern and forest tent caterpillar populations are expected
to be heavy again this year. These insects spin white “tents”
that appear in a branch crotch or tree stem in late April
or early May. Their eggs hatch and the larvae begin feeding
in early spring shortly after leaves begin to appear, causing
defoliation very early in the growing season. Feeding is usually
completed by late June.
Controlling these pests involves pruning off or removing egg
masses prior to hatch or manually knocking the web nests from
the trees. Heavily defoliated trees will often be stimulated
to produce more leaves; however, another disturbance, such
as a drought, may stress trees causing a dieback.
For Fact Sheets about Tent Caterpillars or Gypsy Moths, please
visit: http://counties.cce.cornell.edu/ulster or call the
Master Gardener Hotline, 845-340-3478.
Disaster Prone
The government won’t be ready for another major disaster
such as Hurricane Katrina unless the Pentagon takes a more
aggressive role in the federal response, congressional investigators
said in a recent report which also noted that poor planning
and confusion about the military’s role contributed
to problems after the storm struck on Aug. 29, 2005. It urged
the Defense Department to establish procedures to speed aircraft,
troops and reconnaissance gear to hurricane -stricken areas
when local and state officials are overwhelmed as well as
beef up communications support to Homeland Security officials,
who have the lead role in a disaster.
“The devastation of Katrina and the issues it revealed
serve as a warning that actions are needed,” said the
report by Congress’ investigative arm. “Without
urgent and detailed attention to improve planning, the military
and federal government risk being unprepared.”
In recent weeks, defense officials have stocked up on cellular
and satellite phone vans, begun updating their emergency response
plans and have placed specially trained military personnel
into the Federal Emergency Management Agency regional offices,
the Pentagon has replied.
The report comes as the Bush administration contemplates the
proper domestic role of the military as it faces long-term
obligations in Iraq. Previous White House and congressional
investigations into the Katrina response have said the military
should take on a greater role. President Bush also has said
he plans to shore up the Mexican border with National Guard
troops paid for by the federal government.
Darwinian…
Humans are responsible for the worst spate of extinctions
since the dinosaurs and must make unprecedented extra efforts
to reach a goal of slowing losses by 2010, a U.N. report has
said. Habitats ranging from coral reefs to tropical rainforests
face mounting threats, the Secretariat of the U.N. Convention
on Biological Diversity said in the report, issued at the
start of a March 20-31 U.N. meeting in Curitiba, Brazil.
“In effect, we are currently responsible for the sixth
major extinction event in the history of earth, and the greatest
since the dinosaurs disappeared, 65 million years ago,”
said the 92-page Global Biodiversity Outlook 2 report. Apart
from the disappearance of the dinosaurs, the other “Big
Five” extinctions were about 205, 250, 375 and 440 million
years ago. Scientists suspect that asteroid strikes, volcanic
eruptions or sudden climate shifts may explain the five.
A rising human population of 6.5 billion was undermining the
environment for animals and plants via pollution, expanding
cities, deforestation, introduction of “alien species”
and global warming, it said, estimating that the current pace
of extinctions was 1,000 times faster than historical rates,
jeopardizing a global goal set at a 2002 U.N. summit in Johannesburg
“to achieve, by 2010, a significant reduction in the
current rate of biodiversity loss.”
“Unprecedented additional efforts’ will be needed
to achieve the 2010 biodiversity target at national, regional
and global levels,” it said. The report was bleaker
than a first U.N. review of the diversity of life issued in
2001.
About 190 nations met in Germany in recent weeks to try to
bridge vast policy gaps between the United States and its
main allies over how to combat climate change amid growing
evidence that the world is warming. The May 15-16 “dialogue”
involved around 40 rich nations which are capping emissions
of heat-trapping gases under the U.N.’s Kyoto Protocol,
as well as outsiders such as the United States and developing
nations.
“Scientific evidence of the dramatic effects of human-induced
climate change is becoming stronger,” said Richard Kinley,
acting head of the U.N. Climate Change Secretariat. “Governments
need to agree on how the world is to reduce emissions within
two to three years.”
President George W. Bush denounces Kyoto as an economic straitjacket
that unfairly excludes developing nations from a first round
to 2012 even though almost all his industrial allies back
the scheme. Rather than binding caps on emissions, Bush favors
big investments in technology such as hydrogen or solar power.
Many developing nations say that rich states should take the
lead in cuts before asking them to restrain emissions.
“The dialogue will take the form of an open, non-binding
exchange of views, information and ideas,” the United
States said in a note to the Bonn talks of senior officials,
reminding them of a limited mandate agreed in Montreal last
year.
Us Vs Them
Middle-aged, white Americans are much sicker than their counterparts
in England, startling new research shows, despite U.S. health
care spending per person that is more than double what Britain
spends. A higher rate of Americans tested positive for diabetes
and heart disease than the British. Americans also self-reported
more diabetes, heart attacks, strokes, lung disease and cancer.
The gap between countries holds true for educated and uneducated,
rich and poor.
“At every point in the social hierarchy there is more
illness in the United States than in England and the differences
are really dramatic,” said study co-author Dr. Michael
Marmot, an epidemiologist at University College London in
England.
The United States spends about $5,200 per person on health
care while England spends about half that in adjusted dollars.
“Everybody should be discussing it: Why isn’t
the richest country in the world the healthiest country in
the world?” Marmot said.
Smoking rates are about the same on both sides of the pond.
Britons have a higher rate of heavy drinking, but a higher
percentage of Americans are obese.
The researchers crunched numbers to create a hypothetical
statistical world in which the English had Americans’
lifestyle risk factors. In that model, in which the English
were as fat as the Americans, the researchers found Americans
still would be sicker.
Only non-Hispanic whites were included in the study to eliminate
the influence of racial disparities. The researchers looked
only at people ages 55 through 64, and the average age of
the samples was the same.
Americans reported twice as much diabetes as the English:
12.5 percent vs. 6 percent. High blood pressure was reported
by 42 percent of Americans and 34 percent of English. Cancer
showed up in 9.5 percent of Americans and 5.5 percent of the
English. The upper crust in both countries were healthier
than middle-class and low-income people in the same country.
But richer Americans’ health status resembled the health
of the low-income English.
Health experts have known the United States population is
less healthy than that of other industrialized nations, according
to several important measurements. For example, U.S. life
expectancy ranks behind that of about two dozen other countries,
according to World Health Organization statistics.
Some believe the U.S. has lagged because it has a more ethnically
diverse population than some of the higher-ranking countries,
like Iceland and Sweden, said Richard Suzman of the U.S. National
Institutes of Health. But the new study showed that when minorities
are removed from the equation, and adjustments are made to
control for education and income, white people in England
are still healthier than white people in the United States.
One possible explanation may be the United States has been
going through an obesity epidemic that only just recently
has begun impacting the United Kingdom. Because the most recent
data in the study is at least three years old, the disparity
in the two nations’ obesity problems may seem especially
pronounced, he said. Marmot offered an explanation for the
gap: Americans’ financial insecurity. Improvements in
household income have eluded all but the top 20 percent of
Americans since the mid-1970s. Meanwhile, the British saw
their incomes improve, he said.
Robert Blendon, professor of health policy at the Harvard
School of Public Health, said the stress of striving for the
American dream may account for Americans’ lousy health.
He was not involved in the study. “The opportunity to
go both up and down the socioeconomic scale in America may
create stress,” Blendon said. Americans have more chances
to both succeed and fail. They do not have a reliable government
safety net like the English enjoy, Blendon said.