Sad News...
Larry Shurter, son of Jesse and father of Raecine, passed away
last week. We don’t have all the details as of deadline
but will fill in on this great man, who was to be commemorated
with a floral race in the shape of one of the race cars he loved
so, and gained at least part of his lasting fame from (for a
while, he ran his own local race course). He lived on High Point
Mountain Road but grew up in Samsonville. He was a man of great
stories and strong opinions, of deep friendships and a quick
wit and ample gentility. We’ll give you more, as he so
deserves, next issue...
Flood Aid?
Art Snyder, Director of the Ulster County Emergency Communications
and Emergency Management Department, has announced that the
Disaster Recovery Center (DRC), which has been set up at the
Town of Ulster Town Hall, will no longer have Sunday hours.
In addition, those individuals seeking to file a FEMA claim
for lost or damaged property must do so by June 18. “Governor
Pataki declared Ulster County a disaster area on April 18th
and, by law, those victims have 60 days to file claims with
FEMA. This does not mean claims will be settled by that date,
but those people who fail to register by the 18th will not be
able to participate in the program,” stated Director Snyder.
Any questions regarding this information should be directed
to (845) 331-7000.
Overspent
According to the county Treasurer’s Office 2004 annual
financial report, Ulster County spent $270.2 million, $19.5
million more than the $250.7 million took in through taxes and
other revenue sources last year, and ended the year with just
$1.2 million in reserve, a fund balance decrease of $12.4 million
from the previous year. Ulster’s situation is in sharp
contrast to neighbors Dutchess and Greene Counties, both of
which ended 2004 with surpluses. It has been determined that
the county may have to take out short-term loans to meet its
financial obligations throughout the year, the first time it
has had to do so since the early 1990s, because of the lack
of a fund balance to act as a financial stabilizer.
Several factors contributed to that operating loss including
the loss of $3.9 million in Intergovernmental Transfer Program
payments to the Golden Hill Health Care Center, larger-than-expected
retirement costs, an increase in medical and hospital premiums
and principal payments on county debt, plus the fact that sales
tax was about $1.5 million less than expected.
About 65 percent of county spending is mandated, leaving spending
in areas such as the Golden Hill Health Care Center, the sheriff’s
road patrol and the Office for the Aging as discretionary…
all of which are now looking at possible cuts. New revenue sources,
including a possible home heating tax, property transfer tax,
mortgage tax, and higher motor vehicle registration fees, are
currently under consideration.
Casino Watch
According to state Senator John Bonacic, when Governor George
Pataki releases his much anticipated legislation in the coming
weeks to settle land claims with five Indian tribes, including
the Seneca-Cayugas, in return for casinos, it will stipulate
that a casino can only be built with the approval of the local
county legislature. If the governor’s legislation does
not include such a condition, Bonacic said he would insist on
an amendment to ensure local control. According to Bonacic,
a service agreement between the Ulster County Legislature and
the tribe would be required before the process could proceed
further.
If the Oklahoma-based Seneca-Cayuga Indian tribe is successful
in gaining approval to operate its casino in Saugerties, it
would mark the first time in U.S. history that a tribe is permitted
to do so outside of the state where its reservation is located.
The Seneca-Cayuga tribe is proposing to build just under four
million square feet of resort/casino/retail space, a 900-room
hotel, a 750,000-square-foot convention center, a 20,000-seat
sports and entertainment arena, a PGA-level golf course, and
five parking garages to accommodate approximately 23,000 parking
spaces at the Winston Fawm site of the 1994 Woodstock reunion
concert..
In April, 2003, Pataki and Attorney General Eliot Spitzer, through
their attorneys, wrote a letter to the federal government which
stated that awarding jurisdiction to out-of-state tribes would
“open a Pandora’s box.”
“The governor flip-flopped; that’s exactly what
he did,” said Bonacic, who believes Pataki has since come
to view casino revenues as a means of funding a court-ordered
increase in aid to New York City schools of some $26 billion
over the next six years.
Pataki withdrew legislation in mid-April authorizing five casinos
in the Catskills to settle land claims with the Seneca-Cayugas;
the Wisconsin Oneidas; the Stockbridge-Munsees of Wisconsin
(whose claim reportedly involves less than an acre of land);
the landless Cayuga Nation of New York; and the Akwesasne Mohawks,
whose land borders the Canadian provinces of Ontario and Quebec
as well as New York State. Pataki spokesperson Todd Alhart has
said that the state needed to revise the agreements in light
of a March 29 U.S. Supreme Court ruling, which held that the
New York Oneidas could not purchase property and operate it
as tax-exempt holdings without going through the federal land-to-trust
process. Federally approved Indian trust lands are considered
sovereign, the reason Native Americans are able to operate casinos
on them in states where gambling is otherwise illegal.
Sullivan County legislators have already voted by a margin of
two to one in favor of casinos there, according to Bonacic,
who believes the Seneca-Cayugas are “fishing” to
“test the pulse” in Ulster County. “I’m
not so sure the political climate is as receptive to casinos
in Ulster County,” he said.
The state is under a court order to settle its land claim with
the Cayuga Nation. The Seneca-Cayugas are a party to that lawsuit
and they have agreed to drop their claims in return for a casino.
Following an appeals process, the Federal District Court awarded
the Cayugas a $250 million judgment and 64,000 acres of land.
The state will have to pay interest on that amount until the
settlement is concluded.
Meanwhile, the New York Oneidas reportedly have an option on
the former IBM recreation facility in Lake Katrine.
Last week, Ulster County Legislators Peter Kraft, Robert Parete,
Michael Berardi and Legislative Candidate Brian Cahill sent
out a call for the immediate formation of a special county committee
to discuss and prepare for casino development proposals in the
Towns of Saugerties and Ulster.
Crash Records
According to the 2004 annual report issued by the Ulster County
Traffic Safety Board, more than 4,000 people were injured and
31 people died in traffic accidents in Ulster County last year.
Speed and driver inattention were listed as the leading causes
of accidents locally, factors compounded by the general lack
of wide shoulders along the roads, which provides some buffer
for out-of-control vehicles.
Officials said in cases where a vehicle goes slightly off the
road, high speed and the lack of a proper shoulder on most local
roads can cause drivers to overreact and lose control of the
vehicle, rather than slowing down and gradually steering back
onto the roadway.
Another pattern that has led to numerous accidents in the area,
which was a contributing factor in many fatalities, is drivers
crossing the center line of the roadway into oncoming traffic.
Fifty percent of the fatalities did not have a seat belt on,
and half of those were back-seat riders not wearing a seat belt,
and half of those were ejected from the vehicle.
Motorcycle, and pedestrian and bicycle crashes were up over
the previous year, and in most cases, the accident was the fault
of the walker or rider and not the driver.
Charter Chatter
The 11-member bipartisan Ulster Constitutional Charter commission
backed the 2003 public referendum that calls for shrinking the
Legislature from 33 to 23 members, who will run in single-member
districts, rather than the multi-member districts currently
in place, beginning with the 2011 election.
A substantial change recommended by the Charter Commission is
shifting the responsibility for drawing new Legislature districts
every 10 years from the Legislature to an independent body of
at least seven members, a move several commissioners said would
add more integrity and transparency to that process. The commission
also recommended that legislators’ salaries should be
determined by an external body rather than by the Legislature.
Another change the panel favored was shifting from two-year
to staggered four-year terms for legislators, a move many felt
would give lawmakers greater independence in the move away from
having legislators spend more time trying to get re-elected
than doing the county’s business.
The commission was split on the issue of term limits. Some said
term limits would allow for a greater level of participation
in the Legislature by the public, while others said they thought
that term limits would result in some of the most qualified
members of the Legislature being tossed out of office despite
being effective lawmakers.
The commission hopes to finalize its recommendations in the
late summer or early fall. The recommendations then will be
put before the public for input and adjustments will be made
as deemed necessary to reflect public input. Then a final charter
document will be given to the Legislature at the end of 2005.
The Legislature’s approval of the charter is required
before it can go to the public for a vote. Ulster County currently
operates under provisions of the New York State Home Municipal
Law. A county charter allows a more individualized form of county
government in which the structure, duties and balance of power
can be tailor-made to the county’s needs.
Health Care!
Longtime political foes Newt Gingrich and Hillary Rodham Clinton
have started working together to promote legislation on health
care changes, joking that some might view it as a sign of a
soon-to-come doomsday. Clinton, D-N.Y., and Gingrich, the former
Republican House speaker, appeared outside the Capitol this
month to promote a bill that would modernize medical record-keeping.
As first lady, Clinton spearheaded a White House health care
reform effort that failed in Congress. The resistance to her
effort helped fuel Newt Gingrich’s ‘’Contract
with America’’ and his rise to the speaker position
in 1995. A decade later, they sound downright chummy.
Standing next to the senator, Gingrich argued that both parties
should agree to move health care records from the realm of scribbled
doctors’ notes to electronic record-keeping. Proponents
of the measure say the bill would greatly reduce the 98,000
estimated U.S. deaths a year caused by preventable medical errors
such as misreading a prescription.
The 21st Century Health Information Act would create regional
health information networks to help transfer health data quickly
between doctors, hospitals and nurses, and ensure that different
hospitals adopt technologies that are compatible.
The former House speaker told a meeting of newspaper editors
last month that he expects Clinton to win re-election next year,
then capture her party’s presidential nomination in 2008
and have a good chance to win.
‘’Any Republican who thinks she will be easy to
beat has total amnesia about the Clintons,’’ Gingrich
said. He also said she has the added benefit of her husband,
‘’the smartest American politician as her adviser.’’
Cost of War
Fighting in Iraq has been prolonged and remains intense enough
that it has pushed the total cost of US military operations
since Sept. 11, 2001, close to that of the Korean War. And despite
the yawning federal deficit, Congress hasn’t blinked at
this price even though the costs for Pentagon operations are
likely to pile up in years ahead. By 2010, war expenses might
total $600 billion, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
Much depends on when - and how many - US military personnel
can be withdrawn from the Iraqi theater of operations.
The demands and unpredictability of war have, in essence, turned
the defense budget into a two-part allocation. First is the
regular budget request, which contains acquisition and research
and development funds as well as personnel and operations costs,
and which Congress considers in its normal appropriations process.
Second is the supplemental appropriations - the add-on emergency
spending requested by the administration later in the year.
Congress gave final passage to a 2005 supplemental defense bill
just this past month.
The cost of the US military in Iraq is running about $5 billion
a month. Overall, Congress has approved about $192 billion for
the Iraq war itself, according to an analysis by the Congressional
Research Service. Another $58 billion has been allocated for
Afghanistan, and some $20 billion has gone for enhanced air
security and other Pentagon preparedness measures in the US.
That has far exceeded the $85 billion inflation-adjusted price
tag of the 1991 Gulf War, which was largely paid for by contributions
from US allies.
As for all military operations combined, add in the $50 billion
in war spending the Senate Armed Services Committee last week
added to the fiscal 2006 defense budget bill, and the total
will surpass $320 billion in US funds… close to the Korean
war level of $350 billion [in today’s dollars]. The Congressional
Research Service pegs the cost of US operations in Iraq and
Afghanistan at an additional $458 billion through 2014.
Late news further revealed that the $82 billion in wartime supplemental
funding that was approved May 10 by Congress still won’t
be enough to pay for military operations through the rest of
this fiscal year, which ends Sept. 30, since congressional aides
have reported that the services have indicated they will need
even more money by August — possibly even earlier —to
cover rising operational and maintenance costs of the protracted
war in Iraq. The exact amount is unknown because defense and
service officials have just started their review, but lawmakers
expect a request for about another $50 billion before summer’s
end.
No Answer
Eighty-nine Democratic members of the U.S. Congress recently
sent President George W. Bush a letter asking for explanation
of a secret British memo that said “intelligence and facts
were being fixed” to support the Iraq war in mid-2002.
The timing of the memo, published by the Times of London was
well before the president brought the issue to Congress for
approval. British officials did not dispute the document’s
authenticity, and Michael Boyce, then Britain’s Chief
of Defense Staff, told the paper that Britain had not then made
a decision to follow the United States to war, but it would
have been “irresponsible” not to prepare for the
possibility.
The White House has not yet responded to queries about the congressional
letter, which was released on May 6 and “raises troubling
new questions regarding the legal justifications for the war
as well as the integrity of your own administration...”
“It seemed clear that Bush had made up his mind to take
military action, even if the timing was not yet decided,”
the memo released in London said. “But the case was thin.
Saddam was not threatening his neighbors, and his WMD capability
was less than that of Libya, North Korea or Iran.” Britain’s
attorney general advised that “the desire for regime change
was not a legal base for military action” and two of three
possible legal bases — self-defense and humanitarian intervention
— could not be used. It further charged that inadequate
plans were being made for the aftermath of an anticipated invasion.
The Bush Administration has called the memo, and the letter
from Democrat congressmen, “nothing new” even though
denying such matters in the past two years.
Ah, Intelligence
State Assemblyman Daniel L. Hooker, R-Saugerties, introduced
two bills on May 3 requiring the teaching of “intelligent
design” in New York state public schools and allowing
the posting of the Ten Commandments on government property.
Hooker is the sole sponsor of both bills which have been referred
to committee. The Institute for Humanist Studies (IHS), a nonprofit
think tank in Albany that promotes secularism in government
and education, opposes both bills, noting how Ten Commandments
and “intelligent design” controversies have arisen
in Kansas, Pennsylvania, Alabama, Tennessee and Texas.
“I am shocked that a legislator in a progressive state
like New York would propose such backward and unconstitutional
legislation,” said Tim Gordinier, IHS director of public
policy and education. “Both bills would violate the First
Amendment protections against government establishment of a
religion. The government has no business promoting religion,
yet that is precisely what Assemblyman Hooker is proposing.”
Assembly bill A08036 requires that all students in New York
state public schools, from Kindergarten through Grade 12, receive
instruction in both “theories” of intelligent design
and evolution. The bill also requires the board of education
or the trustees of every school district to provide appropriate
training and curriculum materials for the teachers.
“Intelligent design” promotes the idea that life
is simply too complex to have been created without an “intelligent
designer.”
Assembly bill A08073 would allow for the Ten Commandments to
be displayed as a historical document in public buildings and
on public grounds in New York state.
The Institute for Humanist Studies offers an online course on
“Evolution, Creationism and the Nature of Science”
at www.HumanistEducation.com.
Patriotism?
The Bush administration and Senate Republican leaders are pushing
a plan that would significantly expand the FBI’s power
to demand business records in terror investigations without
obtaining approval from a judge. The proposal, which is likely
to be considered in a closed session of the Senate intelligence
committee in the coming weeks, would allow federal investigators
to subpoena records from businesses and other institutions without
a judge’s sign-off if they declared that the material
was needed as part of a foreign intelligence investigation.
Furthermore, the proposal, part of a broader plan to extend
antiterrorism powers under the law known as the USA Patriot
Act, was concluded by Republican leaders on the Senate Select
Committee on Intelligence in consultation with the Bush administration,
Congressional officials said.
Administration and Congressional officials who support the idea
said the proposal would give the FBI a much-needed tool to track
leads in terrorism and espionage investigations that would be
quicker and less cumbersome than existing methods. They pointed
out that the administrative subpoena power being sought for
the FBI in terror cases was already in use in more than 300
other types of crimes, including health care fraud, child exploitation,
racketeering and drug trafficking.
But word of the proposal has generated immediate protests from
civil rights advocates, who said that it would give the FBI
virtually unchecked authority in terror investigations, and
the plan is likely to intensify the growing debate in Congress
over the balance between fighting terrorism and protecting privacy
rights.
Support for the idea among many Democrats and some Republicans
in Congress is uncertain, and the Senate intelligence committee’s
plan to push the proposal could set off a struggle with the
Senate Judiciary Committee. The Judiciary Committee has joint
authority for oversight of foreign intelligence surveillance
law - which would be expanded under the current proposal - but
its members have shown some reluctance to expand the FBI’s
counterterrorism powers.
Anti-Poverty…
Up to 20 million Britons are expected to protest against world
poverty as part of the biggest mobilisation against global inequality
ever seen this summer. In addition, 250,000 campaigners are
planning to attend a rally in Edinburgh to coincide with July’s
G8 summit where key talks among world leaders could witness
British Prime Minister Tony Blair securing a historic deal to
help Africa’s poor. Meanwhile, the BBC is understood to
have cleared its schedules on the same day as the Edinburgh
march in anticipation of a huge global event. Although the show
of public support is expected to help bolster Blair’s
efforts to secure a breakthrough on debt, aid and trade, concern
is rising in Whitehall that the key measures are failing to
win US support. Although officials maintain that plans to double
international aid to around $100 billion a year and eradicate
much of the debt of poor countries remain intact, privately
they warn that agreement may not be reached during the talks.
A series of protest marches in Paris, New York and Berlin among
others will culminate in the Edinburgh rally when tens of thousands
will encircle Edinburgh to create a ‘human wristband’.
No Recruits
The U.S. Army ordered a one-day suspension this month of its
recruiting efforts, already made difficult by the Iraq war,
to confront incidents of misconduct by its recruiters. The incidents
included a Texas recruiter threatening a man with arrest if
he did not show up at a recruiting station for an interview
and Colorado recruiters telling a high school student how to
get a phony diploma from a nonexistent school, Army officials
said. On May 20, all 7,545 recruiters at 1,700 recruiting stations
nationwide were counseled by Army officials about what is permitted
and what is not in the effort to coax people to enlist, officials
said.
The Army is already struggling to meet recruiting goals, with
potential recruits and their families wary about volunteering
to serve during wartime. Aiming to sign 80,000 recruits in fiscal
2005, the Army has missed its goals in three straight months,
including falling 42 percent short in April, and is 16 percent
behind its year-to-date recruiting target.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Army has announced that it will allow recruits
to sign up for just 15 months of active-duty service, rather
than the typical four-year enlistment.
America abolished the draft in 1973 during the tumult of the
Vietnam War era and has since relied on a military made up exclusively
of volunteers. This is the first time the new all-volunteer
army has faced a serious, long-term war.
Under the new plan, new recruits will be offered the option
of serving 15 months on active duty after completing their training,
and then two years in the part-time Army Reserve or National
Guard. The soldier then would spend nearly seven years in the
Individual Ready Reserve, which requires no training and until
recently was rarely mobilized, or serve in a program like the
Peace Corps.
NPR At Odds
Executives at National Public Radio are increasingly at odds
with the Bush appointees who lead the Corporation for Public
Broadcasting. In one of several points of conflict in recent
months, the chairman of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting,
which allocates federal funds for public radio and television,
is considering a plan to monitor Middle East coverage on NPR
news programs for evidence of bias. The corporation’s
board has told its staff that it should consider redirecting
money away from national newscasts and toward music programs
produced by NPR stations. Top officials at NPR and member stations
are upset as well about the corporation’s decision to
appoint two ombudsmen to judge the content of programs for balance.
And managers of public radio stations criticized the corporation
in a resolution offered at their annual meeting two weeks ago
urging it not to interfere in NPR editorial decisions.
The corporation’s chairman, Kenneth Y. Tomlinson, has
also blocked NPR from broadcasting its programs on a station
in Berlin owned by the United States government.
At the request of two senior Democratic members of Congress,
the inspector general at the corporation is examining whether
Mr. Tomlinson’s decision to monitor only one television
program, “Now,” with Bill Moyers, and his decision
to retain a White House official who helped create guidelines
for the two ombudsmen may have violated a law that is supposed
to insulate public broadcasting from politics.
Last month, the corporation’s board, which is dominated
by Republicans named by President Bush, told the staff at a
meeting that it should prepare to redirect the relatively modest
number of grants available for radio programs away from national
news, officials at the corporation and NPR said.
Diabetics Beware
A dismal two-thirds of the nation’s 18 million Type 2
diabetics don’t have their blood sugar under control,
putting them at high risk of the disease’s nastiest complications,
even death. Yet most are unaware they’re doing so poorly,
frustrated diabetes specialists have said. Type 2 diabetes is
the most common form of the illness, and experts estimate a
third of the people who have it don’t know. An additional
41 million have ‘’pre-diabetes,’’ an
impaired sugar tolerance that can lead to the full-blown disease.
Type 2 diabetes sneaks up on you, as the body gradually loses
its ability to use insulin, a hormone crucial to converting
blood sugar into energy. High glucose levels damage blood vessels
and nerves - eventually leading to blindness, kidney failure,
amputations of feet and legs and heart disease. Diabetes is
the nation’s sixth-leading killer.
Tight control of blood sugar, either through diet and exercise
alone or with a variety of medications, can prevent that damage.
The best measure of control: the A1C test, a way of tracking
average blood-sugar levels over two or three months.
‘’The American public largely doesn’t understand’’
this disease, said Surgeon General Richard Carmona, who urged
patients ‘’to take their treatment seriously.’’
Muslim Hatred…
A new report finds that the number of reported bias crimes and
civil rights violations against Muslims in the United States
soared to its highest level last year since the period immediately
after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The Washington-based
Council on American-Islamic Relations, which did the study,
attributed the increase to lingering animosity toward Muslims
and a growing use of anti-Muslim rhetoric by some political,
religious and media figures.
Notable bias or discrimination cases cited in the report include
the barring of singer Cat Stevens and Islamic scholar Tariq
Ramadan from entering the United States and the arrest of a
Muslim lawyer from Oregon jailed as a “material witness”
in the terrorist bombing of Madrid trains based on a fingerprint
that turned out to belong to someone else.
“We believe the disturbing rise in anti-Muslim hate crimes
and in the total number of civil rights cases, both of which
will be outlined in our news conference, can be attributed at
least in part to rising Islamophobic rhetoric in American society,”
said Arsalan Iftikhar, the council’s legal director.
The council counted 1,522 incidents in which Muslims reported
their civil rights had been violated in 2004, a 49 percent increase
over 2003. Another 141 incidents of confirmed or suspected bias
crimes were committed against Muslims, a 52 percent rise.
The report did contain some good news. Workplace discrimination
complaints - 23 percent of all 2003 complaints - fell to less
than 18 percent last year. Complaints involving government agencies
fell from 29 percent in 2003 to 19 percent last year.
Bigger Atlantic
The European Union and United States edged closer to a World
Trade Organization showdown recently as airplane maker Airbus
said it hoped to win controversial funding from Britain for
a new jet intended to compete with Boeing Co.’s latest
offering, the 787 Dreamliner. Airbus, owned 80 percent by top
European aerospace company EADS and 20 percent by Britain’s
BAE Systems Plc, has also asked France for new loans, a spokeswoman
for France’s transport ministry told Reuters.
Washington warned it could resume a World Trade Organization
case aimed at getting the government loans declared illegal
under world trade rules.
The United States and the EU suspended competing WTO cases over
government aid for Airbus and Boeing in January in the hopes
of reaching a negotiated settlement. However, they failed to
achieve that by an April deadline. EU officials said negotiations
with the United States to avert a trade war were still underway.
The bilateral clash reflects the corporate battle between Airbus
and Boeing. The U.S. company, which dominated the market for
decades, is fighting back after losing the lead in deliveries
in 2003. The EU says that the United States showers it own aid
on Boeing through government contracts and state tax breaks.
Bad Wasps
The discovery of a pernicious wasp in New York, the first time
it’s been found in the wild in this country, has scientists
worried about a scourge that has devastated pine forests in
other parts of the world. E. Richard Hoebeke, a Cornell University
entomologist, collected the Old World woodwasp on Sept. 7 in
Fulton County northwest of Albany as he sifted for bark beetles
caught in screening traps. He identified the adult female bug
on Feb. 19. The invasive insect species, Sirex noctilio Fabricius,
has ruined up to 80 percent of pine trees in areas of New Zealand,
Australia, South America and South Africa, Hoebeke said. If
established in the United States, it would threaten pines coast-to-coast,
particularly in the pine-dense Southeast.
The woodwasp, which is native to Europe, Asia and northern Africa,
kills pines and sometimes other conifers by introducing a toxic
mucus and spores of a toxic fungus when the female lays her
eggs through the bark and into the sapwood. The only other woodwasp
in the United States was found in 2002 in Indiana but that was
in a warehouse, not the wild, Hoebeke said.
Scientists from the U.S. Department of Agriculture will test
areas around where Hoebeke found the woodwasp. If one of those,
or another species of interest, is found, the researchers will
set traps in greater density to determine the scope of infestation.
Because the bug likes stressed wood, scientists will also examine
facilities such as mills that make packaging materials out of
wood that is unfit for uses like construction. They’ll
also use aerial photography to identify stands of pine that
look unhealthy.
The wasp is about an inch long and has a broad waist and distinct
antennas. Since 1985 U.S. Department of Agriculture Animal and
Plant Health Inspection Service inspectors have intercepted
seven male woodwasps at border points; all had come with tile
and marble imports from Spain and Italy.
Hypocrisy 101
Heated criticism has been growing over ‘double standards’
by Washington over human rights, democracy and ‘freedom’
as fresh evidence emerged of just how brutally Uzbekistan, a
US ally in the ‘war on terror’, put down recent
unrest in their country. Outrage among human rights groups followed
claims by the White House that appeared designed to justify
the violence of the regime of President Islam Karimov, claiming
- as Karimov has - that ‘terrorist groups’ may have
been involved in the uprising. Critics said the US was prepared
to support pro-democracy unrest in some states, but condemn
it in others where such policies were inconvenient. Witnesses
and analysts familiar with the region said most protesters were
complaining about government corruption and poverty, not espousing
Islamic extremism.
Scott McClellan, the White House spokesman, tried to deflect
accusations of the contradictory stance when he said it was
clear the ‘people of Uzbekistan want to see a more representative
and democratic government. But that should come through peaceful
means, not through violence.’
Uzbekistan is believed to be one of the destination countries
for the highly secretive ‘renditions program’, whereby
the CIA ships terrorist suspects to third-party countries where
torture is used that cannot be employed in the US. Dozens of
suspects have reportedly been transferred to Uzbek jails.
The CIA has never officially commented on the program, but flight
logs obtained by the New York Times show CIA-linked planes landing
in Tashkent with the same serial numbers as jets used to transfer
prisoners around the world. The logs show at least seven flights
from 2002 to late 2003, originating from destinations in the
Middle East and Europe.
Critics say the US double standards are evident on the State
Department website, which accuses Uzbek police and security
services of using ‘torture as a routine investigation
technique’ while giving the same law enforcement services
$79 million in aid in 2002. The department says officers who
receive training are vetted to ensure they have not tortured
anyone.
Wine Freedom!
Wine lovers may buy directly from out-of-state vineyards, the
Supreme Court ruled recently, striking down laws banning a practice
that has flourished because of the Internet and growing popularity
of winery tours. The 5-4 decision overturns laws in New York
and Michigan that made it a crime to buy wine directly from
vineyards in another state. In all, 24 states have laws that
bar interstate shipments. The state bans are discriminatory
and anti-competitive, the court said.
‘’States have broad power to regulate liquor,’’
Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for the majority. ‘’This
power, however, does not allow states to ban, or severely limit,
the direct shipment of out-of-state wine while simultaneously
authorizing direct shipment by in-state producers... If a state
chooses to allow direct shipments of wine, it must do so on
evenhanded terms.’’
While the ruling only involves wine sales, industry groups expect
that it will soon apply to beer and other alcoholic beverages
currently regulated through state-licensed wholesalers and retailers.
The Washington-based Institute for Justice says the 24 states
that ban direct shipments from out-of-state wineries are Alabama,
Arizona, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Indiana,
Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan,
Mississippi, Montana, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, New Jersey,
New York, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah and Vermont.