Follow Up on the News


Comp Plan $

The DOT grant actually funds the planning of an even more ambitious concept than the original Phoenicia Riverwalk, a hamlet revitalization plan that included a continuous recreation trail running along the part of the Esopus that backs Phoenicia's Main Street. As outlined in the Comp Plan Committee's expanded River Corridor Connected Community project, the grant would pay for planning to link all the hamlets in Shandaken with biking, hiking,skating, horseback riding, skiing, water-travel and rail trails. The grant includes $27,000 in direct funds to hire a planner.Funds were awarded to the Town under a DOT program providing technical assistance to municipalities for the preparation of transportation elements of their comprehensive plans.

The announcement of theaward was made at the outset of Monday night's Comprehensive Plan meeting by committee chair John Mathiasson, who was clearly pleased to be able to spread such good news in light of tense atmosphere surrounding the committee's work in recent months. In an effort to address criticism from the community and integrate comments received since its January Public Hearing, the committee had previously decided to put its work on hold until aplanner could be hired to oversee continued work on the plan's draft.


Until Monday's news regarding the grant, the committee had intended to temporarily cease its meetings altogether, however the availability of funding means that the committee will need to continue meeting to move along the process of identifying potential planners.


Mathiason said that with this grant in hand, there would now be money to hire such a planner and that the committee should put its work on the actual plan on hold until that was done. Later, that issue was raised again, as the grant was for a specific component of the overall plan, not for its entirety. In fact, the another grant for $15,000 was applied for to New York State Department of State (DOS) to hire aplanner to oversee the whole plan. Mathiason had word from the DOS recently that the grant was likely to be funded and that the announcement would be made by the end of March.


Several questions arose as to how the work of each section would dovetail if two planners were involved; if it were possible to start work on the River Corridor plan without having arrived at the whole plan; and whether it would be possible to just break the project off from the comprehensive plan.

Eventually, after considerable discussion and some acrimony between members of the committee and from the audience, it was decided that Mathiason should consult with the DOT to find out if the scope of work for the project changes given the situation the committee now finds itself in.


Because of the likelihood that the committee will receive the $15,000 DOS grant to hire a planner, the committee decided to put out a Request for Qualifications in the New York State Contract Reporter to find out what planners are available for the job. That way the committee will be able to move expeditiously to hire a planner once the grant is awarded.Other issues discussed at the meeting included what role the planner would play; whether votes taken by the committee should be decided by a simple majority or a super majority and if one more fairly represented the wishes of the community than the other; and what percentage of written and oral comments from thepublic hearing were in favor of the draft plan.


After some discussion, it was decided that the planner would act as a facilitator within the committee, working with as much of the gathered material as necessary. The meeting ended with the committee agreeing to put its work on hold until the planner was hired.

Unless the committee needs to meet sooner because of something Mathiasson learns after speaking to the DOT, the next meeting will be held in a month on April 14 at 7 p.m.


Belleayre

High on the list of concerns for many in attendance was the possible impact of a major expansion of the facility on the hamlet of Pine Hill. Various plans floated since the mid-1980's have called for its downhill expansion into the hamlet, though at this point Lanza is negative on
the subject. "We're not going into Pine Hill. It's absurd to think we could put a lodge or parking there, and it would be irresponsible to develop a plan that would have any vehicular access via Bonnieview Road. It's conceivable there could be some kind of pedestrian walk-in if the community wanted it, but that's not part of our plans."


How the residents of Pine Hill feel about this is by no means clear, though many do seem open to the possibility. "Pine Hill's inns and restaurants are the ideal compliment to the facility at Belleayre", says Adam Nagy, Chair of the Catskill Heritage Alliance, and a supporter of other initiatives to revitalize the hamlet. "A stronger link with the ski center would only reinforce that".


Current Plans being developed by the mountain's staff however, do in fact call for a new lift to be constructed in proximity to the hamlet, though one reachable only from elsewhere on the mountain. That proposed lift would be the longest in the Catskills at 7,700 feet, creating for Belleayre a skiable vertical drop of nearly 1,700 feet, a figure greater than that at Hunter or Windham, the region's two larger ski areas.


That lift is just part of a substantial proposed rebuild of the mountain's trail system and its major facilities to accommodate projected growth. Five years ago, Belleayre saw 71,000 skier visits with revenues of just under $2 million. This season to date, it's seen 158,000 skiers, with a
record 171,000 projected and revenues that could top $5.5 million. According to Lanza, plans in development call for a buildout to accommodate an expected 250-260,000 skier visits per year, based on a design capacity of 9,000 skiers per day and up to 10,800 during peak weekend periods.


This year's peak weekend days topped out at 5,200 skiers. At the time of Belleayre's construction more than 50 years ago, it's main, "Overlook" lodge was built at an elevation of over 2,500 feet to assure access to a natural snow cover. Modern snowmaking equipment however has made high elevation lodges somewhat inefficient, both operationally and for skiers seeking the longest possible run between a mountain's summit and its base facilities.


Plans in development call for the construction of a large new base lodge in proximity to the current Discovery Lodge, with significantly expanded parking. Additionally the mountain's planners are calling for a buildout of its trail system from its current 17 miles to 25 miles, the maximum allowed under the State Constitution at the time of the facility's creation. Going forward, the process of exploring the expansion will continue to include significant community input. DEC's administrative guidelines for its Unit Management Plans require updating every 5 years, and include provisions for local review committees.


Formal approval of plans such as those being considered require their inclusion in its UMP, though flexibility exists with respect to timing, as such plans are procedures, not state law. Belleayre Mountain is administered as one of two "Intensive Use Areas" within the Catskill State Park, along with North & South Lake in the Town of Hunter.
Belleayre's success in recent years at reinventing and remarketing itself are apparent in it's remarkable growth curve. According to Joe Kelly, longtime Chair of the Coalition to Save Belleayre, "our success has had a lot to do with Tony being there, and a lot has to do with funding. The fact that we're successful is a big boost to the area, and right now we're probably the most successful state-run operation in the whole State of New York . We can see how our local economy ebbs and flows with how Belleayre's doing. It's good business for us."


School Budget

The least thrifty strategy, which would save $600,000, entails keeping students in their current schools but reducing staff through creation of several multi-age classrooms. The fourth plan is a hybrid, which entails using the Princeton Plan at West Hurley and Woodstock andmulti-age classrooms at Phoenicia, with no change at Bennett and a savings of $780,000.


Rowe's presentation was preceded by business administrator Chuck Snyder's outline of the budget crisis which precipitated the proposals. Snyder cited unavoidable cost increases such as the 12 percent increase in health care premiums, the rise in required donations to the teaching and non-teaching employee retirement funds, and the scheduled debt payment for the construction at Bennett. These increases would cause a rollover budget-without any increases in programming-to go up $4.3 million or 11.18 percent, from this year's total of $38 million to $42.6 million, raising the tax levy by 16.67 percent. A contingency budget, which would result if the board's budget were defeatedtwice at the polls, would limit the rise to approximately three percent, or $1.1 million, with a tax increase of 5.37 percent. The administration, therefore, is attempting to reduce spending by $3.1 million, down to the contingency budget level, under the assumption that higher taxes could not be borne by the voters.


Adding to the crisis is Governor Pataki's threatened state aid cut of $1,150,000, which may be restored in the final state budget, but the government has failed, year after year, to finalize its budget until after the school budget vote in May, leaving school districts uncertain about how much revenue they can expect. Another problem, said Snyder, is
the state's new policy to delay paying out building aid until eighteen to twenty-four months after new construction is completed in order to solve the state's cash flow problem. This year's state aid may also be delayed into the next school year. Snyer urged concerned parents to write to Pataki in opposition to such tactics, including the proposed aid cuts. "The politicians don't want to raise [state] taxes, but it's getting passed on to us at the local level."


Trustee Marty Millman said that when he sat on the board ten years ago, the budget was $19 million. "Now it has doubled. Will it double again in the next ten years? When will we stop the bleeding?" Snyder again pointed to the state government, which has passed more and more laws mandating programs in schools but has not funded forty percent of the cost of its mandates, as promised. "They've never given us more than fifteen percent," said Snyder.


Another factor is the decreasing enrollment in the elementary schools, where class sizes have dwindled, in many cases, to fifteen or less. Rowe's proposals all aim at increasing class sizes in order to reduce staffing, the biggest expense in the budget. "One of the things done in the district is to acknowledge that the desire people have for neighborhood schools is so powerful," he said. "We have been willing to maintain that and lose a lot of our efficiency in the use of space in the schools. But now it is not possible to maintain low taxes and low class sizes. We will need to shake the patterns people have fallen into that make them comfortable."


Trustee Greg Walters asked what would happen if the West Hurley school were closed, and then enrollments went back up. Rowe said demographic data collected four years ago indicate that the elementary-age population will continue to diminish for at least three years, and the recent enrollments confirm the accuracy of the projections, although he admitted it may be time to update the data. Parent Jim Sofranko had pointed out earlier that post-9/11 migrations from New York City may skew the figures upward, but Rowe said he was confident the district would be able to operate comfortably for at least five years with only three elementary schools. Meanwhile, BOCES may want to lease the West Hurley school, which would keep it in operation as an educational facility, enabling the district to re-open it as an elementary school in the future if necessary.


BOCES has indicated that its willingness to lease the building would depend on its needs for next year, but Rowe said, "Ever since I've been here, BOCES has been looking for space. They may consider us to be in the hinterlands, but I think they'd take it."


Rowe briefly discussed the Princeton Plan. "Some experts argue that the benefits of K-6 schools are continuity and a sense of community. Advantages of the Princeton Plan are that it clusters together more teachers and students with the same goals and grade levels. It would also reduce the disadvantages of having kids coming from four different elementary schools. It would be two different schools and would resolve some of the problems of the transition to middle school." While there would be some increase in transportation costs because of the duplication of bus routes, Rowe did not feel this expense would be a deciding factor. "We have two hundred kids now on variances," attending schools outside their designated school area, he observed.


Board member Meg Carey asked whether variances would still be available. "There's a good chance we could continue to have variances," Rowe answered. "It depends on the balance" of students in each school and whether there is room in target classes. Board president Marino D'Orazio asked that parents bring their questions to the two special meetings scheduled to discuss the reorganization options. The first meeting was to take place on Wednesday, March 12, at the West Hurley Elementary School at 7:00 p.m. The second will be on Tuesday, March 18, at Bennett Elementary School in Boiceville, also at 7:00 p.m. D'Orazio suggested that parents form groups of like-minded individuals and designate a spokesperson for each group to speak at the meetings, in order to encourage "an exchange of information instead of people shouting at each other."

Based on the feedback from the community at these forums, Rowe plans to recommend to the board which of the four options to pursue, along with his budget proposal, at the March 24 board meeting. D'Orazio praised Rowe and Snyder for giving thorough background information on the plans, saying they had "diffused a lot of problems I was anticipating."

Barbara Boyce said the staffing portion of her Pupil Personnel Services budget could not be determined until the board settles on which of the reorganization options to choose. She has trimmed non-staffing expenses down to the minimum, with the expectation that students requiring special education and related services (academic intervention, homework programs, remedial reading, etc.) will remain approximately the same. If staffing is not reduced, her budget total will go from $7,097,000 to $7,274,000, a rise of 2.49 percent.


Interim director of secondary education Frank Gorleski presented the instructional budget, which will also be dependent upon the reorganization decision. The operational portion of his budget is cut from $171,603 this year to $131,000, a 25 percent reduction. His proposal would enable summer school programs to continue but would reduce such expenses as conference attendance, journal subscriptions, reference books, in service training for some areas, and school evaluation services.


Laura Claridge

And variety isn't just evident in Claridge's work, but in her life as well. Born in Clearwater, Florida, she's lived in Germany, Washington, D.C., New York City and has now settled in Chichester. In high school Claridge at first thought she'd be a singer, playing Luisa in the Fantasticks, later switched to English in college, then joined the army—though she considered herself a pacifist-- taught English at a naval academy, and has now made a name for herself as an historian of art and culture. The adjectives gutsy and trailblazing come to mind.


Yet she likes solitude. "I work long hours everyday," says Claridge, "researching and writing. Random House [her publisher] signs book deals and expects them to be done on time." Up early each morning, she first takes care of Zoe, the young dog she and husband Dennis Oppenheimer adopted from a shelter in Delhi in August. "She takes a lot of energy."


After her canine duties, Claridge spends about two hours a day answering and writing emails in connection with her work, another hour doing research on Google, looking up such obscure facts as what the laws on divorce were when Emily Post and her husband Edwin Main Post divorced.


Claridge also makes sure she reads something that doesn't deal directly with whatever subject she's researching because she wants to keep her mind open and sharp. "I feel as if research is in many ways a
sense of spontaneous insights that occur as you're adding pieces to the mosaic in a fairly random way."


Claridge and Oppenheimer married in 1993, and between the two of them have four children, ages 18 through 29 with whom she keeps in close touch. And what about exercise? A stationary bike sits idle in the kitchen. "I'm trying to put it into my routine."


But Claridge does get out every now and then. "I love walking to the post office. I like that when I'm in there somebody I know usually walks in. I really love Charlie and Sita," she adds referring to Chichester's postmasters. Claridge also loves sitting at the bar at Ricciardella's, eating the pasta with shrimp and chatting with Will, the bartender. And one activity that gets her out and in touch with fellow writers is the bi-weekly book group that meets at Brio's. "They let us hang out there from 2:30 to 5:00, just critiquing each other's writing. We're all working on books. It's a wonderful source of strength."


At the moment, Claridge is writing a book review for the Boston Globe that she's finding particularly difficult. She's extended her deadline until after she's met with the group to get its feedback on the review.


Okay, the military: Claridge married at 19, and her highly independent mother was disappointed in her decision. Claridge was disowned and faced with how she and her new husband would make ends meet. "I was teaching in a high school for troubled girls and one day an army recruiter came to recruit the girls. I went home and said: I've got the solution. We told the recruiter we were pacifists and got to choose where we wanted to go and what to teach," says Claridge, with some disbelief over her moxie.


Claridge entered the Army with one child, and while there became pregnant with another. "I was considered fairly insubordinate," says Claridge. "I got very angry at the silly dress codes and I'd deliberately flout them." While in the Army, she wrote to a four star general about the lack of daycare. Claridge says she doesn't know if it was because of her, but in a convention that took placeshortly after in Munich, daycare was a major subject.


Later she taught English at the Naval Academy in Annapolis, Maryland. Claridge brought style to the academy, wearing lavish and flamboyant outfits to her classes each day. She realized that the students were making bets on what she'd wear—long skirt, mini-skirt, casual or Chanel. "The women felt empowered by me. They were so sick of wearing the same drab uniform." But the students took her classes seriously, and enrollment grew while she taught though liberal arts were discouraged by the administration.

After teaching for 11 years, Claridge realized she wanted to write. She chose the subject of the flamboyant and decadent 1920s painter de Lempicka because she found that no one had written about her yet. From there, she moved onto Rockwell and is currently working on Post.


Local Business

Jordan flips aside hangers of various Metallica and West Coast Chopper shirts to reveal Che Guevara portraits, Anti-Flag and American Head Change emblems, the latter with President Bush's face on it. There are also lots of the seemingly requisite "I'm With Stupid" brand shirts. And leather pants. And shoes with band and brand insignias. It's your usual mall-oriented over-supply of product.


"I wouldn't do anything if someone wore a peace T-shirt," Jordan says, when asked how the Mall handled enforcement of its little-known policy to keep "offensive" statements off people's shirts. "I don't know who would do anything, except maybe the security guys."


TSX owner Arthur Fine of Shokan, who also keeps a store at Crossgates, said he'd always thought of America as a free country… but added that he'd run into similar trouble back when he owned a T-shirt store in Danbury, CT, where a customer wearing a t-shirt with obscenities on it took his case to court.


"I urge people to be careful about what they wear in the mall," he said.
The Crossgates story started Monday evening, March 3, when Stephen Downs, a 60-year old attorney with the state Commission on Judicial Conduct, was arrested for trespass after he refused to either take off a T-shirt sporting the most benign of anti-war messages, or leave the premises. Downs had bought the offending shirt, and had the statements put on it, at a mall store much like TSX. On the back of his shirt was the statement, "Peace on Earth."

Downs' son, Roger, 31 of New Baltimore, also bought a custom shirt that read "No War With Iraq" and "Let Inspections Work." Subsequent news coverage of the arrest, which went international by Tuesday evening, noted how mall security guards were called by an employee of another mall store when they saw the two men emerge from the store wearing their new t-shirts.


Security Guard Robert Williams responded to the call, and confronted the Downs in the Crossgates Mall food court, where he asked that they take off their T-shirts, leave, or be arrested. Roger did so but his father, stating his legal occupation, said he didn't think he had to. Williams returned with a Guilderland police officer who arrested and handcuffed
the 60-year old attorney, then spoke with him for an hour asking Downs "to drop the whole thing and take the shirt off" according to reports. He was repeatedly told the mall was private property and what he was wearing was unacceptable, the same as if he went to someone's home wearing something unacceptable.


"I said it's not the same thing, it's not a good analogy," said Steve Downs, who later insisted he wasn't protesting or demonstrating by wearing the shirt. Guilderland Town Justice Kenneth Riddett released Downs on his own recognizance and set a return date of March 17. Two days later, The Pyramid Companies, a Syracuse-based company that owns 17 malls, countless senior citizen and student housing complexes, and office buildings throughout Upstate New York, dropped all charges. But then on Friday, they fired Williams, the security guard who was originally called in to confront the Downs.


Protests of between 100 and 250 people have occurred at the Crossgates Mall in defense of both Wiliams and the Downs, on three occasions since March 3. "Mall management determined the customers in question were violating mall policy," added Earl Wells of E3, speaking from a car phone in the Rochester area Monday morning.

"Courts have affirmed that shopping malls have the right to restrict actions and behaviors deemed inconsistent with a shopping environment.""I've ordered new t-shirts," Fine said about TSX. "People are asking for the Give Peace A Chance shirts. I'm also making Peace Is Not A Crime ones. We won't display them, but it'll be there," he said. "I'm pro peace, always have been. But I don't want to upset people."


Aren't you glad we don't have malls here in free-speaking Shandaken?


Defensive

Vice President Dick Cheney served as Halliburton's chief executive officer from 1995 to 2000. The company has since come under heavy pressure because of concerns about its liabilities and a probe by the Securities and Exchange Commission into its accounting for cost overruns on construction projects.


At the time Cheney retired as CEO of Halliburton, to run along side George W. Bush for control of the White House, the company awarded him a $20 million dollar retirement package, saying it was their legal prerogative to increase the size of that package at any time to any amount they desired.


KBR is the exclusive logistics supplier for both the Navy and the Army, providing services like cooking, construction, power generation and fuel transportation. The contract recently won from the Army is for 10 years and has no lid on costs, the only logistical arrangement by the Army without an estimated cost. The New York Times noted recently that the government business has been well timed for Halliburton, whose stock price had tumbled almost two-thirds in the last year because of concerns about its asbestos liabilities, sagging profits in itsenergy business and an investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission into its accounting practices back when Vice President Dick Cheney ran the company.


Halliburton has declined any comment and referred all questions to the
Defense Department. Meanwhile, Halliburton Co. the world's No. 2 oil field services firm, did announce last week that it has started a probe involving U.S. and Nigerian government officials over theft of a radioactive device used at its Nigerian operations.Halliburton said that it is concerned that the device's radioactive material could be used to create a "dirty bomb," an explosive device designed to scatter radioactivity in a densely populated area.


The device was in a locked storage box that weighs about 200 pounds (90 kg) and is the size of a small car engine block. The device, used in
oil detection, was stolen in early December. Halliburton is saying that its investigation also involves officials from the International Atomic Energy Agency, which has been involved in recent UN searches in Iraq. Cheney is still receiving deferred compensation from Halliburton, but neither the company nor the White House would specify how large his payment will be this year or how long the payments will continue.


This is cash that he's already earned. Yet it's also cash that Halliburton is accruing in part from its activities in Guantanamo Bay and Afghanistan.

HOME


In this issue