Home - Editorial - POV - Masthead - Contact The Phoenicia Times

 

Follow Up on the News


Budget Cuts & Sewer Talk
Town Board Action

Also, according to town Supervisor Peter DiSclafani, expect movement – and some controversy, as usual – after this coming Wednesday’s November 5 budget hearing and vote, when the town holds its monthly meeting a bit off schedule due to the election.
The preliminary budget plan, filled with 4% raises for all public officials and non-union employees plus a whopping 18% increase for the towns ambulance squad, caught attention when first revealed last month, prompting one councilman to note that while this would be a hard winter for town employees it would also be hard for taxpayers.
While the overall hike in the total tax levy is slated to be just under 7%, an increase that most taxpayers in previous years have grudgingly lived with, the levy for the general fund portion of the budget, or the non-highway department half, makes up all of it. In itself, the general fund is slated to leap by 11%, a figure that, in previous years, has made taxpayers squirm and demand an explanation.
In contrast the Highway department side of the budget has an increase of less than one quarter of one percent. With a tax levy increase of only $27,302, the Highway side of the equation drags the general funds increase down.
On Monday, October 27, the board sharpened the budget axe, but has yet to use it. There was discussion of eliminating raises for all elected officials and dropping the raises for employees to only 2%, though nothing was decided. The board is also considering the elimination of the Building Inspector position that was instituted in 2007, though it was noted that the department makes money for the town, so cutting it out and having the county take over the building department chores would also send any revenue from the department out of town and into county coffers.
There are other lines in the budget that could stand reduction, said Councilman Vincent Bernstein, pointing out a $7000 line called “planning and management development.” This year only half that amount was used, and that was for a last minute hiring of a consultant to prepare comments on the proposed Belleayre Resort at Catskill Park.
Other ideas included charging $90 per child for the town’s popular summer recreation program, which has historically been free to residents. The budget for Shandaken Day may also see a cut from $5000 down to $4000. Two local veteran organizations, both which were set to receive $2000 each from the town, may only get $1500 each.
As for the town board agenda expected to get hot at times, as usual, this past Wednesday, DiSclafani noted that a report was in from consultants paid for by New York City to study feasibility for a lower expense reed-bed system to treat wastewater for the town. The supervisor said that he was expecting some flack for not having gone through a lengthy Request for Proposal process for the study, which he said could be done by only a handful of companies, with the one hired clearly the one to hire.
He added, later, that he didn’t expect much from recent rumors about problems between the town and the not-for-profit SHARP Committee, unless it was raised by someone at the meeting.
He did note that with a January 31 deadline for a second look at the possibility of a sewer system to be paid for by New York City fast approaching, he’d like to have another request for an extension considered. After all, he noted, given the current economic climate, any input of $15 million would be nothing to turn down automatically, especially if the job at hand could be brought in for far less.
More after the meeting...


Evaluating Rising Needs
In Shandaken the town’s welfare officer, Eve Smith expects to see the number of those in need increase.
In Olive, meetings have been held amongst town board members and various church officials, and all have been asked to start stocking their larders, and keeping extra spaces free in their homes, in case the worst should happen to their neighbors over the coming months.
“People are losing their jobs and things are more expensive,”Smith said of the region’s fate, and what’s being done to meet it.
Smith, who says her job is to be an advocate for the town’s residents, also noted that people who own homes and have jobs are entitled to receive many benefits as long they meet financial guidelines. By her estimate, a person needs to be making $18 an hour, or more, to make ends meet these days, and she knows there many in town that don’t come close to that.
Smith urges people to cast off old stigmas about “welfare” and seek benefits that can make the difference between keeping your home and losing it. She notes how one local woman she’s been in touch with, who was working until she fell ill, was suddenly unable to pay her mortgage and put food on the table. After choosing the former over the latter, she was convinced to apply for food stamps. Smith said that the program has not gotten the women out of the woods entirely but she is at least able to swing the mortgage payments and get proper nutrition now.
Smith said many families in Shandaken and Olive are in a similar spot.
With cold weather already here, she says now is the time to take a look at what programs are available to help, even if it’s just in case.
Cornell Cooperative Extension of Ulster County is hosting “Save Energy, Save Dollars,” a free Weatherization and Energy Savings Workshop, at several locations. According to Cooperative Extension’s Jude DeFalco, the majority of a home’s annual energy budget is consumed for space heating purposes. But he points out that by adding insulation and using advanced air sealing techniques, a home’s annual heating costs can be reduced by over 85%.
“Even with heating fuel oil at $4.50 per gallon, the annual heating bill for a well insulated and air-sealed 2,200 square foot New York home could be reduced to as low as $200 per year,” DeFalco said. “While it is easiest to insulate and air-seal a home while it is under construction, it is possible to retrofit existing homes.”
Cooperative Extension is hosting Save Energy, Save Dollars, a free Weatherization and Energy Savings Workshop designed to help people reduce their electric and heating bills resulting in significant savings year round, on Tuesday, November 25, 2008 from 6:30pm to 8:00pm at the Town of Shandaken Town Hall. Pre-registration is required, and the workshop is open not just to Shandaken residents but to those in Olive, Woodstock and anywhere else in the county.
All pre-registered attendees will receive a free Energy Saving Gift Pack.
Cooperative Extensions Barbara Grumberg made it clear this week what the idea behind the workshop is.
“SAVE MONEY!” she said. For more information or to reserve a seat call 340-3990 or email: bag23@cornell.edu.
Also, the SHARP Committee, a non-profit housing agency, has low interest loans for heating and energy upgrades for homeowners in Woodstock, Olive and Shandaken. Contact Buffy Kibe at 688-5777 for more information on what is available or stop by the SHARP offices on main street Phoenicia.
As for food, Smith notes that the food programs in Pine Hill and Phoenicia on the second Tuesday of each month are going strong, with literally hundreds of townsfolk benefiting.Ditto church programs at United Methodist churches in Samsonville and Olivebridge.
In addition to the help received by Ulster County Community Action, Smith credits local altruist “Farmer Frank” Nazzaro with helping to make local programs successful with several food supply connections. Plus, the Senior Lunch Program is available for seniors at various locations throughout the area.
Also, the Ulster County Department of Social Services will be at the Shandaken Town Hall to help with applications for Home Energy Assistance Program (HEAP) and other county services between the hours of 9 am and 3 pm, November 18th and 25th. As part of the Ulster County Winter Watch initiative, the Home Energy Assistance Program (HEAP) has set up extended hours at select locations to accept new HEAP and Food Stamp applications only for the month of November.
“Increased benefits and higher eligibility criteria for energy assistance makes this program available for more families as we face this challenging winter season”, said Social Services Commissioner Roberto Rodriguez.
The 2008-2009 HEAP season began on November 3 and will end on May 15 next spring. For more information on HEAP, contact the program offices at 334-5436.
Or call Smith at 845-254-5304, especially if you remain undecided about signing up. Smith is prepared to talk the matter over confidentially and will even go with you to sign up if you need help.
You may also call her if you know of any old cars or stoves or refrigerators. Another issue in town, Smith said, is that there are some locals that actually could be working if they had a way to get to the job. An old car that runs could make the difference between employed and unemployed.
As for the stove and fridge. Smith knows of one local that has neither and can’t afford to get them.
If your gross monthly income is at or below the following you can get help with the cost of fuel this winter.
# PEOPLE INCOME # PEOPLE INCOME
1 $1963 7 $5097
2 $2567 8 $5210
3 $3172 9 $5324
4 $3776 10 $5437
5 $4380 11 $5800
6 $4984 11+ +$450
If you are age 60 or older you can apply by phone. Call Christine Noble at the Ulster County Office for the Aging at 845-340-3006. All others should call 845-334-5000
Stay warm, stay full, and don’t forget... it’s ok to ask for help if you need it, and to offer it if you can


All Solidly Democrat

First off, it needs to be noted that even though our own incumbent state Senator, John Bonacic, did not even face any challenge this year, the body he belongs to as part of the state’s two chamber legislature turned Democrat Tuesday night, November 4, for the first time since 1965, according to unofficial results. In January, tthis will give New York Democrats control all the levers of power in state government, including both houses of the Legislature and the governor’s office, as well as the offices of the attorney general and the state comptroller, for the first time since 1935.
On a county level, current County Administrator Michael Hein, who shifted parties from GOP to Democrat a few years back, handily won election as Ulster’s first County Executive, a four-year post with 41,987 votes to 31,907 for Republican-backed candidate Len Bernardo, an Indpendent roller rink owner from Accord.
On January 1, county government will shift from one run by an elected part-time Legislature and an appointed county administrator, Hein’s former position, to one operated under a county charter and led by Hein, elected by voters countywide and bestowed with broad powers to run the county’s day-to-day operations.
Republican James Quigley, who was endorsed by the Kingston Daily Freeman and Woodstock Times as a possible counterbalance to Hein, despite his having earlier funded a campaign against the two new positions and Ulster County’s new Charter system of governance, was slightly ahead of Democrat Elliot Auerbach, the Ellenville Village Manager, in a race for county comptroller. As of press time, Quigley had 36,621 votes to 36,036 for Auerbach, with about 5,000 absentee ballots still to be counted later this week.
The comptroller serves as the county’s chief accounting officer and auditor and has the authority to audit and certify for payment all claims and charges brought against the county. The comptroller also will have the authority to audit county departments and agencies that have contracts with Ulster County to ensure the county’s money is being spent properly.
In Shandaken, incumbent town board member Doris Bartlett, a Democrat appointed to serve out supervisor Peter DiSclafani’s term last January, easily won reelection with Democrat Doris Bartlett defeated Republican challenger Tina Rice by 912 votes to 538.
Bartlett ran on her record as a former Democratic Party chairwoman, as owner of Mountain Business Services, as an elected town assessor, and on years of work on a variety of town issues and volunteer work at the town’s dog shelter. Bartlett ran unsuccessfully for Town Board in 2005, losing by a handful of votes to fellow town board member Rob Stanley, the only voice against her appointment earlier in the year.
Rice, a Woodland Valley resident, ran as a non-politician and touted her background as a sports-oriented PTA award-winning mom who said she hoped to bring an end to partisan politics.
District by district, Tuesday’s results showed that the Town of Shandaken has continued to shift dramatically to Democrats, with not even Quigley winning anywhere in the formerly GOP-dominated town.
In other races, incumbent democratic Assemblyman Kevin Cahill easily defeated Republican Robin Yess; and longstanding U.S. Congressman Maurice Hinchey handily defeated George Phillips of the Binghamton area, the GOP contender. Both men now join their solid all-Democratic majorities in state and federal government, hopoing to cap long careers with at least two years of increased power to get projects through, despite (and hopefully helping to cure) economic hardships.
In neighboring congressional districts, Democratic incumbents Kirsten Gillibrand of Hudson and John Hall of Putnam County, a former Woodstocker when he led the band Orleans, both won re-election.
State voters also overwhelmingly approved a statewide proposition to eliminate a requirement that disabled veterans be receiving disability payments to qualify for additional credit on civil service exams.
Detailed results of the November 4 election appeared briefly on the Ulster County Board of Elections website late on the evening of Election Day, but was again inaccessible by the morning after... a problem that has plagued the office and county-sponsored website for each of the last few elections.


Planning For New Plans

“There are five task forces; special education, and K-through-12,” Resnick said. “They are for curriculum, culture, climate, graduation and professional development.”
She added that the committee is still looking for people to participate in the task force subgroups.
In other business, which included much talk about school aid reliant on uncertain state budget figures, Interim Assistant Superintendent Sherry Sharpe gave a power point presentation on the process of three school data accountability measures mandated by the state.
Violent and Disruptive Incident Report (VADIR) is data collected on school violence and includes all school districts, BOCES, as well as charter and vocational schools. Sharpe reported that, in this round-up, Onteora is considered a safe district.
Basic Education Data System (BEDS) gathers professional and demographic information on staff and Student Information Repository System (SIRS) gathers all accountability and assessment data on students. Sharpe said that all of this data is cumbersome to collect, leaving no stone unturned, and noted that all data is available to the public in the school report card section found on the State Education website.
Former school board trustee Herb Rosenfeld was given an award of recognition for his five years of service. Several school board trustees spoke about the inspiration they received from him, noting his lifetime dedication to education. Rosenfeld spoke a few words of wisdom and said his time as a board member was, “Great Fun.”
“You have to work together,” Rosenfeld noted. “You don’t have to like each other but you are people who are undertaking something whose work is very significant and you have to work together.”
The school board approved a sustainability policy as drafted by the district’s Green Committee. The implementation of the policy will need cooperation from board members, administrators, teachers, students and parents. The policy outlines the five R’s: Rethink how we use and purchase materials, energy and natural resources; Refuse excess materials whenever possible; Reduce the amount of material and energy used; Reuse materials when appropriate; and Recycle.
Two weeks ago, at Onteora’s final October meeting, Superintendent Leslie Ford said the Middle/High School auditorium would close for renovations after the holiday concert in December. She said the district is currently working on the bidding process. When the auditorium re-opens it will have new lights, curtains, backdrops, ventilation, sound system, seats, carpet and doors, as well as repairs made to the floor and stage.
Joyce Long, the new Director of Pupil Personnel for the Onteora school district who recently replaced Barbara Boyce, gave a presentation on the special education department, offering statistics on students who have been placed in special education by making comparisons to county and state averages. Overall, she said the district average currently stands at 19.6 percent of students classified in special education. The high school has the highest classification rate of 21 percent compared to the Middle and Elementary schools, that fall below 17 percent. The last district report card in 2006-2007 listed the district as averaging 14.9 percent of classified students.
“The State likes us to be at around 12 percent, so you can see we are a little higher than the typical district in our areas as well as the State,” Long said, adding that the County average was 12.4 percent.
Long explained that the increased rate partly had to do with students moving from other districts.
“Transfer students this year have been really really high,” she said. “I am actually kind of surprised at how many kids transferred within the first month of school.”
She noted that 14 students have entered with IEP’s (Individual Education Plan) and also received a “couple of referrals.” She said she asked the staff why they believe “so many kids are needing our use in special education” and was told some of the problems have to do with inconsistencies of programs, lack of technology, lack of intervention plans and co-teaching problems.
The outcome, Long concluded, were three goals; Define current programs, Appropriate classification of students by making sure they have the correct programming, and Maintain consistency in services.
Trustee Michelle Friedel asked if the new state-mandated RTI (Response To Intervention) program would help keep classifications down. She also wondered whether kids in need of special education might not be getting the help they need early enough.
Long explained that schools provide help through regular education at a much faster pace, even for struggling kids not needing special education. The RTI program, she added, also acts as an early way to detect if a child needs special education, by monitoring progress through intervention.
Friedel said, “Now, with Response To Intervention coming in, the regular teacher is going to have to learn some of those strategies. I mean, they know some but now they will have to learn more.”
She further asked about consistent staff development.
Long replied that it was important for teachers and co-teachers to move together, with an emphasis on changing curriculum to fit a student’s needs, and modifications so education can fit into all learning styles.


A Challenged Catskills

Those, outlined and specified by scientists, policy specialists, and the public, ranged from new climate change data that predicts the region to be more like North and maybe even South Carolina a generation from now to gas drilling and a weakening economy.
The idea behind the first Catskills Environment & Economy Day, sponsored by the Catskill Institute for the Environment, the Catskill Center for Conservation and Development, the Open State Institute, the Watershed Agricultural Council, and the Catskill Landowners Association, as well as the DEC, was to augment the annual Local Government Day sponsored by the Catskill Watershed Corporation, held the day before, and set a framework for new thinking about the region’s present health and future.
Reports included talks about the threat of air pollution, climate change and invasive species on the region’s forests; challenges to the management of water quality and quantity; trends involving Eastern Brook Trout, the status of local bird populations; where farming now stands in the region, including a look at the recent “Pure Catskills Buy Local campaign;” and forest management updates.
Much was made of an increasing amount of new research on the Catskills ecosystem coming from local colleges and institutions, including the Bard Institute for Environmental Policy and the Nature Conservancy of Eastern New York’s Rising Waters initiative, as well as a growing number of symposiums being planned to address the topical science of climate change over the coming months.
But it was public questions regarding actual steps that might be taken to protect the region that had attendees at the SRO event in the state-owned Belleayre Ski Center’s Main Lodge abuzz. And, more specifically, worries about climate change effects in the region that predominated.
“One has to be politically active,” said Senior Scientist Gary Lovett of the Millbrook-based Cary Institute for Ecosystem Studies when asked what could be done now to avoid worsening problems in the future. “To tell you the truth it’s going to take some fairly drastic changes in the way our economy runs.”
Mike Flaherty, the DEC’s Regional Fisheries Biologist, said there have to be major shifts in the way culverts are put in under roads to better protect fish populations, as well as the health of water supplies.
Others spoke of shifting away from incandescent light bulbs, being “more like Europe” in our embrace of wind power and “real responsibility,” and finally knocking back the reoccurrence of acid rain effects by “no longer pretending we can burn coal cleanly.”
Asked whether this would all entail new regulations, the standard answer was that the State Environmental Quality Review Act’s laws were designed for such considerations… but then the federal lack of leadership on environmental issues was loudly lamented. While some talked about how states would have to fill the breach left by eight years of Bush administration oversight failures, others noted the “truly global” aspects of what was already occurring, and predicted to happen.
Janeway spoke, after comments about the need for new legislation dealing with probable increases in regional flooding over the coming decades, about the state’s need to balance conservation and economic concerns… and separately look closely at how climate concerns would effect the region’s, state’s, and world’s economic health.
Later, after it was established that the threat of climate change in the Catskills was unanimously acknowledged by those in attendance, Janeway spoke about a new state task force looking at the threat of rising waters in the Hudson Valley, and new initiatives moving through the state legislature.
Several people spoke about things reaching a point where NIMBY opposition to wind power generators in local communities, which stopped a planned project in the Delaware County town of Andes last year, would have to end. Otherwise, it was noted, the choice would be to move back to coal power, and increase the push for gas drilling in the region.
“It is no longer a neutral choice,” said Hames, noting how his own school had shifted away from possible wind power back to coal because of local opposition. “If you think a windmill looks bad, look at the alternatives.”
His comments, in turn, raised questions and comments about how most NIMBY arguments could be subverted if the electrical and power grids were broken down and alternative power sources, such as hydro or wind power, could be created for individual communities, utilizing less industrialized infrastructure.
Lisa Rainwater, the new Executive Director of the Catskill Center, talked about ways to reinforce sustainability in the region, from shifting the vegetables we eat to a more seasonable, localized rationale, to restructuring the state’s tax code to support forest landowners’ stewardship activities.
When the inevitable Catskills question about bolstering local residents threatened by declining demographics came up, Dr. Dan Palm of the Watershed Agriculture Council spoke about growth through high tech infrastructure, allowing the Catskills to ride new trends in the Capital region and Hudson Valley. He talked of replacing dairy with niche farming and new markets in carbon trade-offs that could pay top dollar for the replanting of local forests where fields now lie fallow.
When Councilwoman Helen Chase of the Town of Olive noted how Canadians were making fertilizer from wood chips and livestock manure, Palm and New York Farm Bureau representative Chris Kelder spoke about giving it a try… as well as looking into ways of using new pelletizing technological breakthroughs to heat local communities (see sidebar).
“I hope this isn’t just dialogue,” said Janeway in closing comments he shared with the director of his neighboring DEC region to the north, Schenectady-based Gene Kelly. “We can learn a lot from our partners around the world, as well as our partners right here in this room.”
All agreed everyone in attendance would stay in touch via e-mail… with updates on further meetings and other events all promised to set up over the coming winter.