2/28/2007

Dear Editor,
Last Sunday February 17, 2008 my twenty-one month old daughter Tamara died suddenly in the arms of my wife in our house in Boiceville, New York. She was not sickly. She was not expected to die. She contracted a common stomach bug in the morning and around ten hours into the sickness she looked up at my wife and said "hold me". My wife held her and she died within seconds. 911 helped us to conduct CPR. The volunteers came, the ambulances came. The medical workers were amazing but nothing could be done. We rushed to Benedictine hospital In Kingston. I had to drive myself (where incidentally my cellphone did not work most of the way because of our unfortunate lack of cell towers). My wife was in the ambulance with our daughter. Nothing could be done at the hospital. Tamara was declared dead. My wife and I lost our most precious love, the light of our world, in an extremely short period of time. There was no real explanation as she was not dehydrated, they did not think it was the stomach bug, etc...We only know this now after an autopsy. We will most likely never have a concrete answer according to the medical professionals that have been involved in this case including Tamara's pediatrician, the kind Danielle Cigliano from Pine Street Pediatricians.
I am writing to explain what happened right after she died in the hopes that nobody will ever have to go through what we went through. We were interviewed immediately after her death by a detective, Mario Restivo, with a note pad at the hospital. Mr Restivo was decent but it was clear that he needed to investigate why such a terrible and unusual thing had happened. My wife and I were not allowed to leave the hospital. The police requested that we go to the State Trooper Station so that they could take a report that very night. It had to be that night. We drove ourselves in our own car behind a trooper car to the State Trooper Station on Rt 209.
Immediately upon getting to the police station they separated my wife and I. It would be hours before I would see my wife again. They kept me in the waiting room. There was no one there for any type of support -- no social worker, no counselor. There was no phone. There was no water cooler. Not even a police person sat with me to try to comfort me. The simple ironic request was for me to "relax".
Eventually, investigator Restivo brought me into a little room with a desk and had me go through the entire story. I did my best thinking that I would be able to get back to my wife at some point soon. The investigator eventually left the room to print out the report which he had me read and sign. This process took about an hour. I was sent back to the waiting room.
I asked investigator Restivo if I could see my wife: "no" and was told she had actually just begun the procedure of giving her report. An unidentified police officer brought me water at my request - the smallest size dixie cup that exists. He left immediately after handing me the cup.
I was left back in the waiting room and told once again to "relax." There was absolutely no help from the State Troopers - but not just that. They still would not let me see my wife for even a minute.
I was going insane waiting for my wife and finally I begged the officer at the window to get me any help he could. He held up a sign with a phone number on it so that I could call on my cell phone (he mimed me talking on a cellphone). It was the Woodstock Help Line from Family. I spoke to a woman Julia on that line who literally saved my life. Family is the most wonderful organization I have ever encountered. My cell phone battery died eventually and the same trooper who gave me the numbers brought me to a big room full of troopers where I was allowed to use the phone for the next hour of my wait for my wife. I sat and talked to Julia desperate to hold and see my wife. I was shaking. I was in shock.
My extremely distressed wife was released about five hours after our most precious baby had died. We got back in our car - turned around and saw the empty car seat. My wife and I were absolutely devastated as we drove 35 minutes alone on a dark rainy road to our now empty home. There was no follow up. No one to meet us. No one to even check that we made it home okay.
I understand the police obligation to investigate. I appreciate that Investigator Restivo has worked tirelessly to try to find an answer for us since the horrible loss. I personally paid a very high price psychologically for the police treatment immediately following Tamara's passing. The police hurt me more than I can explain with words by isolating me so cruelly. I have been back with my wife, our friends, our community, and our families and we are trying to put our lives back together piece by piece. I do feel hope that my wife and I can heal with a lot of help and time.
I feel an obligation to anyone else that ever has a catastrophic loss to try to protect them from the unfortunate police treatment that wounded me so deeply. I believe that compassion has a place in all public service.
David Baron
Boiceville, NY

Dear Editor,
What is going on in Shandaken, mainly the Highway Depl? In the history of the Highway Dept. there has never been a Deputy Highway Superintendent. Eric announced at the last meeting that one of the members of the crew would be Deputy at no cost to the town. This was passed. The problem with this is no employee can be both a union worker and in management. What were they thinking? Didn’t anyone on the board look Into this before creating this position? There is a foreman.
What happened this weekend? Where were all the trucks? How many of us were sliding around because the roads were not sanded? I did see them out early the other morning when there wasn’t a flake in the air.
Has anyone seen our $44,000 a year Superintendent riding around checking the roads? This is why he wants a Deputy, so he can run his own business while someone else is doing his town job. I heard over the scanner this weekend two of our town trucks had problems. I found out that Eric was home and never showed up either time. Isn’t it his job (if he doesn’t check the roads) to at the very least stay at the garage to see that all the crew are back safe.
Now that I’ve mentioned scanners, it’s back... the nasty talk. Do we really have to hear one crew member tell another that act to perform on him. Eric, get control. Eric said he was going to run his department like a business. Why did he put the Phoenicia sidewalk project out for bid? This was a State Grant. The crew are more then capable to do the work. At the time of year when things are slower, when we all see extra men standing around a truck. This would have at \east paid the salary of 5 or 6 men for about the same amount of time. The town could have saved at least $20,000. Guess it was too much for him.
Eric has complained he is sleep deprived. Maybe he is not the man for this job.
M. Mitchell
Shandaken, NY

Dear Editor,
From my Pine Hill home, I have enjoyed the magical beauty of seeing bear, deer, beaver, fox, turkey, heron, and hearing so many songs from a variety of birds. On behalf of our local wildlife whose very existence is in grave danger, I will be their voice!
Plans are already on the table to build a huge resort along with hotel and other amenities of great size, to attract more people here. We're not Vail, Colorado that can handle many enterprises at once. How much more taking of natural resources, habitats, and the magnificence of the Catskill Mountains are going to be plundered? Ongoing entertainment in a radius of 20 miles, are facilities for skiing, swimming, picnicing, hiking trails, lodges, spas, motels, campgrounds, restaurants, and golf. What's next, a mall for rainy day sport?
If this project goes through, get used to more complaints over bears feeding at dumpsters and garbage pails and a lot of roadkill!
We have to protect the order of life, human and creature coexistence. Without one, the other can't survive!
Our voices are needed to stand up to the challenge of preserving, containing and maintaining our wildlife and natural resources. We can do this with continued vocal presence on the project, media involvement, more town meetings, "Save Our Wildlife" signs - also on tee shirts and bumper stickers, these are just a few ideas.
Our legacy to the next seven generations will be a more peaceful way of life, without noise, exhaust fumes, and an overcrowded Route 28! The Eagle Waits.
Edee Gordon
Pine Hill, NY

Dear Editor,
The announcement of a $700 million plan to build “an entertainment city” on the site of the long- closed Concord Hotel may not be a cause for celebration for everyone but there probably won't be much organized opposition, either. Homeowners knew that the hotel complex down the street was only dormant and could erupt into an active destination resort at any time. The site has all the prerequisites of a successful resort development. It is within 90 miles of New York City and is minutes from the future interstate Route 17. It is near local population centers and there is a large available labor pool. The community already has a suburban feel, the terrain is gently rolling and there are few environmental obstacles. Contrast this situation with the plan for a mega-development west of Belleayre Mountain Ski Center. The Belleayre plan calls for intensive construction on steep, mountain slopes in an unspoiled, rural setting. The site is 140 miles from NY City and 36 miles on local roads from the Thruway. The population and available labor surrounding the site are both low. This precedent –setting development would be built in the constitutionally enshrined Catskill Park adjacent to the “forever wild” Catskill Forest Preserve and in the heart of the NY City watershed-raising myriad environmental red flags. If the reincarnation of the Concord is “smart” development, the proposed Belleayre Resort is the opposite. This contrast explains the friendly reception the Concord proposal will likely receive versus the intense local and national opposition to the oversize and ill-conceived Belleayre Resort.
Matthew Frisch, coordinator
Highmount Preservation Association
Highmount, NY

Dear Editor,
I want to share NY Council TU activities concerning the proposed Belleayre Resort project in the central Catskills and on the planned expansion of the state-owned Belleayre Ski Center. I would like to share our continuing involvement in scrutinizing these projects, as we have proceeded so far contrary to some beliefs.
I. The Belleayre Resort AIP
As you will recall, in September 2007, Governor Spitzer announced an Agreement in Principle that would serve as a framework for advancing a lower-build alternative resort development project adjacent to the Belleayre Ski Center on the border of Ulster and Delaware counties in the Towns of Shandaken and Middletown. The Agreement in Principle was signed by the Governor, the developer, the New York City Department of Environmental Protection and seven environmental groups including representatives of the Catskill Center for Conservation and Development, Natural Resources Defense Council, New York Public Interest Research Group, Riverkeeper, Theodore Gordon Flyfishers, the Zen Environmental Studies Institute and Trout Unlimited.
I signed the Agreement in Principle on TU’s behalf, after consultation with our Catskill Mountains Chapter representative, Roy Hochberg, who had participated in the negotiations with the environmental coalition. I did so because I believed that the Agreement in Principle held the promise for significant new actions to protect cold water fisheries in the Catskills. First and foremost, the Agreement in Principle, if successfully implemented, would insure the transfer of more than 1,200 forested acres just east of Belleayre from the developer to the state for inclusion in the Catskill Forest Preserve as “forever wild.” That action, in turn would completely protect the beloved and threatened Esopus Creek, which feeds into New York City’s Ashokan Reservoir, from the proposed resort development.
In addition, the Agreement in Principle provided a framework for a lower-build alternative on a portion of the smaller parcel to the west of the Belleayre Ski Center. Among those benefits, if the Agreement in Principle is fully implemented, are requirements directing that no individual lodging units in the new lower-build project be constructed on slopes steeper than 20 percent, a mandate that the single golf course be operated as organic, and the transfer of a 203 acre conservation easement from the developer to the City of New York. In total 86% of the entire 1,960 acre site (combined east and west parcels) now owned by the developer would remain undisturbed. (Of course, there are still some water quality issues of concern with respect to the lower build alternative development proposed for the parcel west of Belleayre; I discuss them further in Section III of this memo.)
Another important part of the Agreement in Principle was the public participation process that it created. Specifically, the Agreement in Principle committed the state to undertake a full supplemental environmental review of the Belleayre Resort lower-build alternative project, take whatever mitigation measures may be necessary and insure compliance with all laws and regulations before finalizing the supplemental environmental impact statement or moving ahead with the issuances of permits for any lower-build alternative. The Agreement in Principle also allows TU to fully participate in the public comment process on the draft supplemental environmental impact statement. And as noted later, we fully intend to do so.
II. Belleayre Ski Center Expansion
The Belleayre Resort Project is also related to a second project that has long been on the drawing boards – the creation of additional ski trails at the state-owned Belleayre Ski Center. DEC has stated that it is currently operating 14.5 miles of trails. But it has long been planning to add approximately 9 miles of new trails. Under state law and previously approved amendment to the State Constitution, DEC has existing rights to expand the existing ski center up to a total of 25 miles of trails. So it has been inevitable that some expansion of the ski trails was going to occur, sooner or later. Indeed, it is likely a Ski Center expansion proposal would have been released years ago, but for the ongoing dispute about the proposed Belleayre Resort project. In any event, the details of that expansion and the possible water quality impacts of such a move have yet to be released or analyzed by the public. And of that we are very concerned.
The Agreement in Principle provided a framework for the Belleayre Resort’s lower-build alternative proposed Highmount Spa project to connect to the Belleayre Ski Center via a “ski –in, ski- out’ trail. But the Agreement in Principle dealt with the Belleayre Ski Center expansion only briefly. And it specifically indicated that a draft Unit Management Plan would have to be released in which the details of the proposed Ski Center expansion would be outlined and subject to public review and comment.. And once the Ski Center expansion proposal is released (in the form of a draft Unit Management Plan; UMP), the public (including TU) will have the opportunity to review the specifics of the proposal and its possible impacts on water quality and quantity in detail.
III. Next Steps
I want to emphasize that, despite our significant success in helping to facilitate the transfer of 1,200 acres now owned by the developer to the state for inclusion in the Catskill Forest Preserve and our similar advance in getting New York City committed to acquiring a conservation easement on another 200 acres of the developer’s land on the west, we still have considerable work to do to insure that the Belleayre resort lower-build alternative and the proposed Belleayre Ski Center expansion do not jeopardize Catskills water quality.
The comments prepared on the Belleayre Resort Supplemental Draft EIS by Norman Turner and TU’s Catskill Mountains Chapter are as well written and in detail as the first EIS and subsequent hearings. They are a wonderful set of comments and concerns that again raise many important questions and highlight many critical issues that we believe must be covered in detail in the Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement and forthcoming Draft Unit Management Plan.
When the SDEIS is released, we expect to again prepare expert technical comments – once again in great detail. We plan to again ask the hard questions and raise every legitimate environmental question related to protection of cold water fisheries. One particular concern that TU and the six other environmental groups that signed the Agreement in Principle have relates to potential stormwater impacts from the one portion of the roadway in the Highmount section of the proposed lower-build Belleayre Resort lower build alternative project that would have slopes greater than 20%. We have continued to raise questions about that piece of the plan, as well as the 29 individual lodging units that might be built on or above that portion of the road.
In addition, the proposed Belleayre Ski Center expansion raises a host of water quality questions that have not been the subject of TU review to date. Many of these ski center expansion issues have been addressed by the Catskill Mts. Chapter of TU. We would also plan to review these plans and their water quality impacts with great scrutiny, when the draft Unit Management Plan is released and testify as to our findings and concerns at the public hearings that would follow. As was the case when I signed the Agreement in Principle, the focus of our attention in all these future comments and testimony would not be on traffic or social impacts or other areas outside of our expertise, but limited solely to protection of cold water fisheries, which is of course TU’s mission. It was the impacts on cold water fisheries that was our sole focus during our previous involvement in this matter and it is that issue that we want to guide our continuing participation and review of these Belleayre projects.
On this basis, I affirm that the New York State Council of TU through our local chapters will continue our preparation of detailed comments on the Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the lower-build Belleayre Resort alternative project and on the Draft Unit Management Plan for the proposed Belleayre Ski Center expansion. There is a great deal of expertise within TU on the issues of protection of Catskill cold water fisheries and we want to utilize that expertise in a productive fashion in coming months to secure the protection of 1,400 acres of lands now owned by the developer and to insure that whatever development does occur on the west and whatever expansion of the Ski Center does move forward are done in ways that are fully protective of local trout water streams and their aquatic ecosystems.
Ron Urban, Chairman
NY State Council Trout Unlimited
Port Ewen, NY

Dear Editor,
TRANSPARENT: of a person, etc. - easily understood, frank, open!
Well, I guess the majority of this board missed this lesson in English class! When are you planning on implementing your campaign promise of transparency in government? Better late than never just doesn't cut it!!
The resolution, at the Board Meeting, for the $3000 payment to Ferrandino Associates (to prepare a letter depicting the Town of Shandaken's objections to the entire Belleayre Resort), was way after the fact. Besides, this report was redundant!
There goes $3000 that could have been used for better purposes. Our citizens did NOT have the opportunity to vote on such a decision before it was signed, sealed and delivered. Furthermore, this is NOT the desires of the majority of the citizens of the Town of Shandaken! Get with it---it was against the law and no amount of simpering apologies will make it go away. We are tired of expenditures at the taxpayers expense, of decisions that proclaim the entire population agrees with the NEGATIVE FEW, illegal payments to consultants without the approval of the taxpayers, frivolous law suits that try to delay what's needed in our "Ghost of a Town".
Start working on making improvements that will bring much needed growth, that will perpetrate the health, wealth and prosperity back to OUR TOWN! Then maybe our restaurants will reopen, full time instead of three or four days a week, and our hotels, motels, bed and breakfasts will again flourish, with little shops opening up to salve the shopping appetites of tourists, once again!
John and Jane Rossitz
Shandaken, NY

Dear Editor,
I am writing in response to Judith Wyman’s letter printed in the February 14th edition of this paper. Please note any statements in quotations in my letter are taken verbatim from the tape of the February 4th Town Board Meeting available on public access TV.
Ms. Wyman suggests “get the facts before you attack.” The facts in question are straight forward.
1. Based on telephone conversations with Town Board Members, Supervisor DiSclafani authorized and then paid an outside consulting firm to prepare at a cost of $3,000 comments on behalf of the Town regarding the environmental review of the Belleayre Resort and expansion of the Belleayre Ski Center.
2. At no time, was there a public Town Board meeting to consider hiring this firm or reviewing their comments.
3. The Supervisor stated that when he had read in the newspapers some weeks before that the Town would prepare comments, he found it “completely ludicrous that we could sit down and agree on something.”
4. Realizing the process was “wrong.” Supervisor DiSclafani stated, “we have never had an instance where we had to have such a quick meeting.” He then “took responsibility” for his actions.
5. Supervisor DiSclafani’s idea of taking responsibility for his actions is to put forth and pass a resolution wherein the taxpayers of Shandaken can have ownership in a hastily thrown together set of comments and can pay $3,000 for what he now knows “was wrong.”
Ms. Wyman claims those questioning this process through tone of voice and accusatory gestures were making a blatant attempt to intimidate the Town Board. Those who listen to the tape will hear such incendiary words as: “It was really very unwise.” “Is this what I can expect to see?” “Is this the norm, to pay before a resolution is passed?” “This is inappropriate; could have been illegal; at best it was ethically irresponsible.” From my point of view, not particularly threatening words.
Ms. Wyman claims that the real issue is submitting comments at all. She may have something there. Councilman Rob Stanley pointed out that there will be other opportunities to comment. There was no rush.
There has been no effort on the part of the Supervisor and Town Board to get the facts and become fully informed on a project that has changed enormously with Governor Spitzer’s Agreement in Principle. May be it’s time for the Town Board to really be open and consider more than one point of view.
Martie Gailes
Big Indian, NY

Dear Editor,
The Ulster County Legislature will soon adopt new benchmarks for the Ulster County Development Corporation (UCDC) to meet before it receives funding from the county. While not perfect, the benchmarks are a good start in creating an effective economic development model that is accountable to taxpayers.
Throughout my tenure in the Legislature, I have been part of a vocal minority calling for a change in how Ulster County approaches economic development. In my opinion, our structure of government created a vacuum in leadership that allowed other counties to zoom ahead of us in the competition for high-paying jobs. Until just recently, UCDC and county officials were reluctant to accept change. But now, with our ineffectiveness painfully apparent to all, both sides had no choice but to embrace the new accountability standards.
Hopefully, the new benchmarks will bring a badly needed sense of urgency to our economic development efforts and help us create new job opportunties for this, and future generations of Ulster County residents.
Joe Roberti, District 4
Ulster County Legislature

Dear Editor,
I just watched the Philharmonic concert in North Korea and remembered why I live in this area, where peace is at the foundation of our sacred ground. The cut away's to the audience were moving and quite revealing. At the beginning I wondered if these people knew how to smile, but as the concert went on, there were little beginnings shown on some of the faces. At the end, they were giving standing ovations, and even waves and smiles to the orchestra.
It reminded me that we were right, back in the 60's, when we believed that peace was better than war. I frankly, have never received anything from wars. I never made a nickel out of investments in weapons, boats, planes, or rockets. . So, I favor peace over war.
Now, we are looking at the Democratic choice for our Presidential candidate, and I would like to point out that Obama has said that he wants to talk to our enemies, whereas, Clinton has said that she is against that policy and considers it dangerous. If it is possible, that at the core of all human beings we can find love and humanity, then I do believe that our only hope is to try to touch the hearts of people all over the world. To me peace and music seems the better choice. I commend the Philharmonic for their successful effort to bring music around the world.
Jill Paperno
Glenford, NY

Dear Editor,
In the primaries, Senator Obama has received the most popular votes and the most delegates thus far.
Senator Clinton has not been able to lock up the nomination, so the team Clinton is now directing its attention to the Super Delegates.
Not one name of a Super Delegate has appeared on a primary ballot and not one enrolled Democrat has had an opportunity to vote for or against a Super Delegate. The Party Bosses have hand picked the Super Delegates.
Now the Clinton Machine will try to get the Party Bosses to have the Super Delegates deliver the nomination to the Clintons.
Question: If the Party Bosses go into a back room and steal the nomination from Senator Obama, do you think the Obama followers will support the Clinton Machine in November?
The Party Bosses, in their self interest, and in the interest of the Democratic Party and America should turn the page and move on to the future with Senator Obama.
H. Clark Bell
Woodstock, NY

Dear Editor,
As an uneducated older white woman (right, a Hillary supporter) I'm just plain confused. I guess that Barack Obama is really a uniter after all. He must be.
Here I thought that H. Clark Bell (letter, February 14) was a long time Republican. If so, I suppose then that Bell is disenchanted with Republican front runner John McCain. (Or is he?) Would Bell, by his endorsement of Obama actually vote for Obama should he become the Democratic presidential candidate? What does Bell have against McCain? Is it McCain's support for the Iraq war? (I don't recall ever seeing a letter from Bell questioning or opposing our presence in Iraq, or criticizing Bush, for that matter.) Is it tax policy, or what?
Why is Bell so kindly telling Democrats, for their own good, not to support Hillary Clinton's famous "machine"? Does this warning include superdelegate Maurice Hinchey (who, unlike Obama, actually voted against giving Bush war powers in Iraq)? Could it be that Bell fears that Hillary could beat McCain? Does he agree with Rupert Murdock's New York Post, which also endorsed Obama?
Yes, I guess that Barack Obama is really a uniter. Or is he?
Naomi Stein
Woodstock, NY

Dear Editor,
A dramatized commercial for the National Guard began running during the holiday season at our Hudson Valley Mall Regal Cinema.
The clever ad is pitched to a natural desire of adolescents to challenge their physical endurance and strength of character. It appeals to their idealism. Yet it exploits those very qualities by distorting the reality of National Guard service today.
Promised education benefits, bonuses, valuable skills, non combat opportunities and heroic service are the bait. Yet both the letter and spirit of the enlistment contract are being broken, over and over.
For example, the longest serving National Guard Unit was sent home after 729 days in Iraq. That is one day short of the 730 days needed to qualify for education benefits. Other loopholes result in only a small percentage of vets actually using education benefits.
Veterans with physical and mental injuries are often denied adequate medical care. More than 22,000 veterans suffering from PTSD have been denied medical benefits as the military blames their symptoms on "pre-existing personality disorders." PTSD is a logical result of urban warfare which includes killing innocent people, even children, in a constant state of fear and uncertainty about who is the 'enemy.' Also, 20,000 cases of brain trauma are omitted from the official Iraq casualty tally.
Inadequate rests between deployments to combat are destroying lives and families. Enlisted women are speaking out about rapes and sexual harassment from fellow soldiers. Neither the VA nor the DOD admits the danger to our soldiers and their future children of our toxic and radioactive uranium munitions and vehicle armor.
The war is not 'almost over." 2007 gave us more U.S. soldier deaths - almost 900 - in Iraq than any on the previous five years. The National Guard is not glamorous. It is a backdoor draft, destination Iraq.
If you, like us, do not go to the movies to watch and ad for this Administration's war, speak to the theatre manager or call Regal Theaters headquarters at 877-835-5734.
Enlist For Peace
Joan Keefe, Jane Van de Bogart, Linda Leeds, David Bruner,
Ellen James

Dear Editor,
The passing of Jane VanDeBogart is a loss to more people than we could ever possibly imagine. She touched so many peoples' lives as a humane caring person, and as a fierce fighter for peoples' rights. Her sincerity, selflessness, and courage for all the right causes made a difference for us all locally, and far beyond. She had the ability to challenge ideas and points of view; then break them down to their basic components. Jane had the inner strength to take an issue, own it, nurture it, and watch it grow in the people she came in contact with.
One of Jane's recent major accomplishments is in the process of coming to fruition. Her work, along with other dedicated people, had a direct impact on Women's Reproductive Rights in the merger of Benedictine and Kingston Hospitals. Her legacy will live on in the lives of people she touched. Jane we will miss you.
Don and Linda Gregorius
Woodstock, NY

Dear Editor,
Black are the souls of the warmongers.
Black is what you've worn in the protest for peace.
Silence is what you've spoken when a world should be screaming.
Strong is how you've stood and should be shouldered by millions.
Light is what you've glowed, shining brighter than any bomb.
Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God.
Thomas and Kathy Moretti
Woodstock, NY

Dear Editor,
If terrorists who planned the attacks on 9/11 which took close to 3,000 precious lives are to be given the death penalty, "if found guilty," without a trial in a U.S. court of law, why aren't Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld put on trial before this "military tribunal" for the same charges. They planned an attack on Iraq, even before 9/11, and close to 4,000 courageous soldiers have died, and almost five million Iraqi's have been killed, or displaced to other countries where they will probably die of health related issues (he has destroyed an entire nation that never planned to attack us). Their plan was worse than those on 9/11, because they had no real plan, except three days of shock and awe and the rose petals will be dropped at his feet, and the killing will continue, not to mention wounded both mentally and physically. They are guilty of genocide. Since Bush has thrown out the constitution, he might as well face what the rest of the world sees, U.S. no longer stands for justice for all.
Alan Marker
Accord, NY

Dear Editor,
I would like to thank the teens and parents in our community for coming out and supporting adding education to the Social Host Law.
To all who voted yes to pass the Social Host Law without the educational component, your silence spoke louder then you realize. I do want to thank the 2 legislators who support the educational component.
Bob Aiello - Thank you for listening to the facts and standing up for what is right and not caving to politics. It was refreshing to see your honesty in explaining how many of our legislators go across the street and drink and then drive home after the meetings. Any one that drinks and drives could end up in this same position.
Jeanette Provenzano- Thanks you for being the only person to let the rest of us know we aren't crazy. It felt like we were in the twilight zone. You told it like it was! We are very big in numbers and have many 18 year old voters in our group. You can bet we will be supporting you in any way we can in the next election along with candidates that support these views. You both helped our youth to see that it is ok to speak out for the right reason no matter how much peer/political pressure is out there.
We have the next generation trying to make a difference. They have volunteered their time, some for 2 years.
Why is it that although our former District Attorney has been involved on an underage drinking prevention team for 10 years, Ulster County is still 55th out of 55 counties with the highest incidences of underage drinking, DWI's and deaths in ALL OF New York State? Why is he opposed to an educational component?
Why did it take a group of teens, losing a friend, to create the Alcohol Program for judges to use? The NYS ABC law gives Judges the option of choosing a sentence of $100 fine and/or 30 hours community service and/or completion of an alcohol awareness program.
Not only did we not offer the Alcohol Awareness Program in our county until these teens presented the idea with the help of a clinical supervisor, and also created a phenomenal peer to peer program. We also have no educational component for enabling parents. The group has a qualified professional ready to offer her services at NO COST to our taxpayers. Why then did the former DA say NO and feel the need to use our tax dollars to reinvent the wheel? We need to seriously consider his motives.
The teens have been working with Senior Class President Rose Hallinan and Stephan Bielecki, Administrator of both AWARENESS Teen Mentoring and the newly formed ALCOHOL AWARENESS Group. The AWARENESS MENTORING GROUP, formed in October 2006, involves High School students mentoring Middle School students to have fun without substance/alcohol use. Regardless of reports to the contrary Zephyr Dresser-Peck has never been a mentor or involved with the AWARENESS Mentoring Program).
The Alcohol Awareness Program, which was started when Stephan Bielecki reached out to his friends in the car after the fatal prom night crash to try to impact these situations. Zephyr Dresser-Peck chose to help and is shown as an example of a teen making a very bad decision and suffering the consequences involved. He is NOT a mentor. Dresser Peck has spent countless hours researching and taking additional courses including NYS OASAS certified programs to educate himself and his peers about this subject to help create the best Alcohol Awareness Program possible to break the cycle of these senseless underage drinking deaths each year.
How can the former DA vilify a teen such as Zephyr Dresser-Peck when he is the person who has to wake up every day knowing his best friend is dead because of a bad choice.He already is serving a life sentence for this. Even in his sorrow he has come out and tried to do all he can to help tackle the issue of underage drinking and has brought tremendous public AWARENESS to this problem.
Any parent could be woken in the middle of the night and told that their child has died in a car crash or that their child was the driver in the car. We know that 68% of high school students drink and everyone makes bad choices when they are under the influence of alcohol.
Please help us change society, punitive consequences have been proven not to work. We need to educate and change the culture by having teens teach each other because we adults have been totally ineffective. Who better to teach our teens than those who have made these life changing mistakes that affect us all!
Marie Shultis
West Hurley, NY

Dear Editor,
My name is Rose Hallinan and I am a Senior at Onteora High School. I am an active member of my community and I am the class president as well. About a year ago I helped Marie Shultis form the group called Awareness. This is a group of high school students that mentor middle school students through activities and trips to show that we can have fun without alcohol or drugs. This group was created to try and change the drinking pattern in our community.
A few months ago we also created Awareness II a separate group that once a month holds an educational program. Teens who have received underage drinking tickets are mandated to attend. This group was created to make a step between a ticket that for many holds no significance for many, and a serious tragedy that can occur when kids do not realize the consequences of their drinking.
By working as a mentor I have been able to plan group activities for us to do and interact with younger teens. We have gone on many trips , such as to a basketball game, hockey game, and to a corn maze. We also have had many meetings where we play games and do fun activities. I hope that the time I have spent in this group has changed the way some of the kids think, and I know that with the continuance of this program we will be able to reach out to even more kids. In the future I hope that we will have a dramatic impact on our community to change the culture of drinking once and for all.
Recently, many members of the group have become active with the passage of the Social Host Law. I believe that an education component should be added to the law. I don’t think that $250 and or fifteen days in jail is enough for hosting a party with underage drinking. People sixteen years or older who break this law will continue to have parties if this is the only consequence. The amount of money is nothing, kids will start charging for parties to pay for the fine later! People should be forced to attend an education program related to alcohol awareness, because this is the only way to change behavior. This is why I was extremely disappointed when the law was passed without an education component.
At the board meeting, attention was turned away from the matter at hand to the accident that occurred last May. The accident should have nothing to do with the matter, not one person in the room was opposed to the law. The item in question was if there should be an educational component. Passing the law now or in one month to allow for more time amending the law would truly have no effect. I believe that if the law is left how it is now, in reality it will not change anything. Some people will continue to have parties regardless, and the only way to change this is by teaching people about the danger of parties with underage drinkers, not enforcing meaningless consequences.
In closing, I hope that an educational component will be added to the law as soon as possible. I plan to continue being a member of the group and hope to continue to help middle school students. As the president of my class I feel that it is my responsibility and obligation to change prom this year. I am working on an after prom event and hope that we can change the stereotypical prom night.
Rose Hallinan
West Hurley, NY

Dear Editor,
My name is Erica Beesmer and I am in the 10th grade at Onteora high school. I helped Marie Shultis form the first awareness group in October 2006. I was one of the first awareness mentors. The group awareness is a bunch of high school students that mentor middle school students by doing fun activities in hopes that they will realize you can have fun without drinking. Our group tries to meet once a month and we play fun games or go on trips to basketball games, hockey games, and corn mazes.
After me and some other kids at my school heard about the after prom accident we came to Marie hoping to make a difference and change the way something this horrible happens almost every year! We then formed the group awareness II. Awareness II created a 5 step program that can be used as part of the sentence when teens get a ticket for underage drinking(not drinking and driving) We were trying to get the legislators to add a similar component to the Social Host Law. This educational component would be for parents that let teens drink to teach them of the dangers and in turn have them teach parents of teens that are given underage drinking tickets.
All of the teens and I were very confused as to why only two of the legislators listened as we told them the law as it is now is not strong enough. No one is going to be effected by 15 days in jail or a fine of $250.00. If it's a teen they may think it is cool to go to jail and what kind of things might they learn there that could impact them to be a worse person after returning to society.
We are hoping to change the law so when teens are drinking,caught and charged with DWI's,or even get in a car if they are drunk that they can go through the educational course which I feel will effect them way more then any other punishment. At the legislative meeting last Tuesday I was very upset to see the ways adults were personally attacking an 18 year old boy. I felt that it was very unnecessary at the moment and was uncalled for. As if living with such a horrible mistake for the rest of your life is not enough!
I hope people reading this letter will help us change the laws. If a teen is not old enough to drink then one mistake should not force them to be sent to state prison to be with hardened criminals.
Erica Beesmer
West Hurley, NY

Dear Editor,
Here's to all our friends, neighbors and owners of ugly pants for making the First Annual Ugly Pants Contest in Phoenicia a success! Almost 100 people were in attendance at the fundraiser on Fri., Feb. 8 to strut their stuff and support the Listen to Me Youth Theater's production of Narnia, which will open at the Colony Cafe in Woodstock on March 28 and run through March 30 (for ticket reservations call (845) 688-2068 or email: storydanz@yahoo.com).
With Uncle Rock wailin' tunes, DJ Rick Schneider from WKZE emceeing the event, an amazing spread of wine, cheese and baked goods, along with 40 ugly pants contestants of all ages, it was a night filled with fun and laughter! Dave Channon filmed the event and immortalized it on youtube! To check it out, just go to youtube.com and type in "Ugly Pants Contest"! (or see out video of the week)
And the best is yet to come...we will be exhibiting an entire wall of Ugly Pants Contest photos at the next Arts Upstairs exhibition: "All You Need is Love", which open this Sat., Feb. 16 in Phoenicia!!! So come have a look and see the glamorous photos we snagged of your favorite contestants! All sales benefit the Listen To Me Youth Theater. What better gift for your Valentine than a picture of you (or him/her) in your most flattering attire?!
A special thanks to all the moms, kids, and friends who baked delicious treats for our bake-sale table, Wendy Helm for event planning and design, Uncle Rock for a night of great live music, Rick Schneider for slick emcee-action and publicity, Elaine Cruickshank for ticket sales, The Arts Upstairs Gallery for hosting, Viva Fraser, Christina Byron, Babs Mansfield, and Vanessa Burke for planning and support, Tania Barricklo, Tom Fraser, and Phil Mansfield for photography, Dave Channon for video, the Peekamoose Restaurant for first prize donation, and the Wine Hutch, Woodstock Liquors and Hurley Ridge Market for food/beverage donations.
See you at the Arts Upstairs Gallery AND here's to making next year's contest even bigger and uglier than ever!!!
Cara Cruickshank
Phoenicia, NY

Dear Editor,
What is the Phoenicia Library beyond books? It is a very special place, well-loved by its patrons, yet not well known to many residents of the Town of Shandaken, all of which it serves. It is an information resource, cultural center and vital community space. Its cozy ambience, friendly staff, and strict “anti-shushing” rules make it a place to meet friends and talk to new and interesting people. Its
several computers with broadband access provide a gateway to the digital world.
The library offers books, DVDs, videos, music and books on tape and cassette (with many more available through inter-library loan), magazines, information on government services and community
events, copy and fax services, and much more. The Jerry Bartlett Angling Collection, on the second floor, is the largest circulating collection of books on fishing in the Northeast - and has flies and fishing poles as well. Homework help is available from books, computers, and even other
library patrons. Special workshops for kids and adults occur throughout the year.
Our beloved library is small and cramped. Older books must constantly be discarded to make room for new ones. It lacks handicapped access. Three patrons at once may create a traffic jam. The library is too small to adequately serve its population. We hope to expand in the near future. To do so, it needs help - help with creative fundraising efforts, help with current library tasks like shelving books, help with the bookstore that provides over 5% of the library's annual income.
Much of that help is provided by FOPL - Friends of the Phoenicia Library. This group is made up of people who realize that a good library is crucial to the future of our community. Friends support the Library by: Creating public support and awareness for the library and its programs; Raising money for capital campaigns or for special items; Assisting, supporting or sponsoring library programs and events; Volunteering to work in the library or on specific projects.
Working together, we can accomplish so much more for our library, and help achieve a dream of a library that is has enough space for books, computers, and new technologies, a community room, cozy places to sit and chat, quiet places to sit and read.
Please join us - membership doesn't cost much - $10.00 for a single person, $20.00 for a family membership. Questions? E -mail friendsofphoenicialibrary@gmail.com. Or just pick up a membership form at the library. Old members, please renew your membership. As soon as we have a few new members, we will be having a meeting/get-together at one of our member’s houses.
How many times in the last year have you or someone in your family depended on the library? The library's future is up to YOU.
Michelle Spark
FOPL President

Dear Editor,
It's ironic, I find myself saying "what did you say" more often as time rushes by on its inexorable journey to who knows where. Words become muted but there is a sound that is constantly in the background that becomes clearer and more predominant every year; the intangible audio signature of time passing.
Perhaps it's because as I age my life is less cluttered with superfluous fluff, a luxury allowing for focus on things that, in my core, really matter and are worthy of expenditure of my time. The delineation between burdensome activities and those that are accompanied with a smile is now stark. I try and broker my time judiciously.
I'm cautious about taking on new projects as I sift through my procrastinatory pile of good intentions. (Quite a task if I must say so!) I am constantly hearing my Dad's sage advice, "If in doubt, throw it out." I dare not focus on the facets of each unfulfilled project as I chuck it over my shoulder, for that would defeat the purpose, rather I revel in the clarity of the present it is bringing.
Things in my present field of vision include Karen, my wife and best friend. An unsought gift recognized first by my heart then by every fiber of my being. Our existence is timeless as our Love evolves in the moment…a true blessing.
Watching my daughters negotiate the minefield from adolescents to adulthood; never judging, always there and offering pearls of wisdom when called for is a source of constant smiles.
My home in the country with its mountain views and grounding perspective is my foundation for sanity.
All in all life is wonderful. I sense creeping cantankerousness, but it makes me smile. My body is telling me use me or lose me so I figure it's time to heed the warning.
So if you see someone appearing to drag his feet to slow the circle down that'll be me; stop by and say howdy, we can share a smile.
Bob Nielsen
Boiceville, NY

Dear Editor,
The Phoenicia Rotary would like to thank the following for helping us host our annual exchange student winter weekend:
Russ’ Country Kitchen, your sandwiches and fried chicken are the best. Black Bear Hollow you again provided a terrific lunch for the kids and the box lunches on Sunday were not only delicious but the packaging was truly a “box lunch” presentation. Serge from Al’s Restaurant, wow no one can make a veggie lasagna like you…absolutely a five star dish! Jim McGrath thank you for your patience in outfitting our group with skis, boards and necessary equipment and most certainly Tony Lanza and the Belleayre staff for providing not only a perfect day but superior ski conditions.
This years Rotary Winter Weekend was truly a memorable event that our exchange kids and Rotarians will remember for a very long time.
Chris Baltz
Phoenicia Rotary

Dear Editor,
Family of Woodstock's hotline and walk in center is located in the heart of Woodstock. As you might know, we are mainly a volunteer organization, relying on a network of people to serve the public by coming to Family each week for three to four hours to answer the hotline phones and to help walk-ins with whatever we can. During a typical day we might help an angry teenager, an exasperated parent, a lonely shut-in, someone who needs help with social services, a family that needs food, clothing or shelter, or a person who just wants contact with another human being.
It is the volunteers who are the front line of this exciting work. It is they, through their skills in dealing with a multitude of issues, who offer the community the wide range of services that Family provides. Volunteers learn the skills necessary to listen and respond to others. Our training encompasses elements ranging from basic listening skills to helping people in a variety of crisis situations.
In March, we will be holding a new volunteer training. If you are interested in joining us, and we hope that you are, please call 845-679-2485 to set up an appointment.
Tamara Cooper
Family of Woodstock