September
14, 2006)
Cell Deadline!
If Masterpage Communications doesn’t have a tower
up and operational by May of next year the company’s
contract with the town is null and void. That’s
the word from Supervisor Robert Cross Jr., who this week
was miffed that neither hide nor hair of the company has
been seen for months.
Masterpage, which got planning board approval last spring
to build, has not taken any steps to build despite a promise
that the tower would be up last month.
“They’ve got an 18 month deadline from that
contract for the cell tower to go up,” Cross said
matter of factly.
The contract, negoiated by Cross in one-on-one sessions
and signed in November 2005, gives Masterpage the right
to build the tower on town property.
Route 28 Detour...
State Department of Transporation engineer Lee Zimmer
announced this week that he would be leading a public
information session on his department's plans to close
down a portion of Route 28 in the Boiceville area at 7
pm on Thursday, September 14 at the Olive Town Meeting
Hall on Bostock Road in Shokan. Zimmer added, however,
that the DOT's present plans call for at leats one lane
of the busy highway to be kept open at all times during
the necessary repairs toa 50 foot deep culvert damaged
during flooding this past Spring and summer. He further
noted that road work will not be scheduled until ongoing
repairs to Route 23A in the Greene County "Mountaintop"
town of Hunter gets completed, and that road re-opened,
on or around November 1.
An Ashokan Deal?
Campus Auxiliary Services, the owner of the Ashokan Field
Campus near the Ashokan Reservoir, is negotiating with
The New York City-based Open Space Institute, a land preservation
organization has been protecting portions of the Hudson
Valley and eastern New York for 35 years, about buying
the 372-acre site.
Steven Deutsch, the chief executive officer of Campus
Auxiliary Services, said he hopes to have the sale completed
and the contract signed in the next month or so.
Under a contract with SUNY New Paltz, Campus Auxiliary
Services provides the college with dining, bookstore,
laundry and other services, and the college has used the
field campus for instruction. But now, Deutsch said, Campus
Auxiliary Services wants to shift its resources from the
field campus to projects that impact larger numbers of
New Paltz students more directly.
Negotiations between Campus Auxiliary Services and the
Open Space Institute were facilitated by Jay Ungar’s
Friends of Fiddle and Dance Company, which has held dance
camps at the reservoir since 1980. Ungar, a noted local
musician, wanted to maintain the reservoir’s heritage
and helped form the Ashokan Foundation, a not-for-profit
organization seeking to forge a larger vision for the
campus by combining its educational, environmental, cultural
and artistic elements.
The talks with the Open Space Institute began after the
Circle of Life Camp - a non-profit organization that runs
an upstate summer camp for children and young adults with
diabetes - abandoned its plan to buy the Ashokan Field
Campus.
Besides being used by SUNY, the field campus has offered
outdoor and environmental education programs for local
elementary schoolers for nearly 40 years, and all parties
involved hope to continue the overall mission of the campus.
“We’d like to foster a connection between
all of these that hasn’t really happened before,
because we think music and arts and environment and history
have a lot of common ground, and we’d like to see
the school programs reflect that,” Ungar said.
The Ashokan Foundation’s board of advisers includes
representatives from the Catskill Center for Conservation
and Development and the University of Pennsylvania’s
Center for American Music, Ungar said.
Martens said the Open Space Institute would “absolutely
try to keep the staff and mission going,” and added
that, if the purchase goes through, the transfer will
include a transition period to allow for a hopefully seamless
change.
“We’re trying to help find a way to basically
keep the outdoor education program going and protect the
land in the process,” Martens said. “It is
a beautiful natural site, and at the end of the process,
we hope it stays in much the same condition it is today.”
Snuffy On A Roll!
Friends of Snuffy, Inc, the new Shandaken-based not-for-profit
providing help for the town's animals and their owners,
reports that their first project - fencing for a new dog
exercise area at town hall - is now complete, as are other
improvements to the shelter itself.
The group, which operates totally independently of town
government, was funded by proceeds from the May 28 James
Blunt benefit concert at Belleayre and other donations.
They've also been helping out by taking care of veterinary
bills for dogs in Shandaken's town shelter, and in future
will be looking to assist with cat rescue in town. Donations
may be sent to Friends of Snuffy, Inc., PO Box 237, Shandaken,
NY 12480
Jail Update?
County legislators are worrying that the already overdue
jail might have to wait for a 2007 opening, what with
some new setbacks.
The state commissioner of correction has told Sheriff
Richard Bockelmann that the jail’s requirement of
148 full-time corrections officers could not be met because
seven officers are out on disability. Some county members
are meeting with the commissioner Sept. 14 for a clarification,
but legislators aren’t sure that will give time
for a jail opening,m what with training requirements of
at least two months.
There is also a problem with the bidding process for a
phone system at the facility, and individual cell windows
need to be tinted or blocked somehow, both to prevent
male and female inmates from looking into each others’
cells and to keep inmates from seeing confidential informants
entering the building.
The jail project is already tens of millions of dollars
over budget, but some legislators said that the county
should worry less about cost and more about simply getting
it open.
Rural Transport
A bus driver for Ulster County Area Transit (UCAT) was
arrested twice last month on charges he solicited prostitution.
Chance Ireland, a UCAT employee for less than a year,
was arrested by Ulster County sheriff’s deputies
and charged with fourth-degree patronizing a prostitute,
a misdemeanor. Ireland allegedly solicited an undercover
deputy for oral sex in exchange for money. The alleged
incident took place on Tuesday, August 22, on Ireland’s
bus route at Bob Moser Road and Pavilion Street in the
town of Saugerties. Ireland was immediately transported
to the Ulster County Law Enforcement Center for processing
following his arrest and was later released with an appearance
ticket for an unspecified future date in town of Saugerties
Court. As a result of Tuesday’s arrest, Ireland
was arrested the following day by town of Woodstock police
on the same charges for allegedly offering a male passenger
$100 to masturbate in front of the driver in the Andy
Lee Field in Woodstock on Monday, July 10.
The Ulster County sheriff’s office began investigating
the allegations against Ireland after a male passenger
filed the complaint in July. Ireland and the accuser were
the only people on the bus at the time.
Regional Grants
Quality Communities Program grants totaling several tens
of thousands of dollars have been announced for the Hudson
Valley and Catskills regions by Lt. Governor Mary Donohue.
The largest single grant, of $160,000, was to Putnam County
for its Main Street Partnership Program, a partnership
with the city’s six towns and three villages. In
other grants, the Village of Ellenville will receive $32,000,
Sullivan County will receive $49,450, Ulster County will
get $60,000, the Western Catskills Community Revitalization
Council with the Village of Stamford will receive $52,000,
the Town of Athens will get $58,600, Greene County and
several local governments will receive $50,000, the Town
of Hyde Park will receive $38,000, the City of Peekskill
will get $89,000, the Village of Pelham will get $75,000,
the Village of Rhinebeck will receive $57,500, and the
Village of Walden will receive $30,000.
Poverty Rises
The number of people living in poverty has finally stopped
climbing. Household incomes edged up slightly in 2005,
but 37 million people were still living below the poverty
line, about the same as the year before, the Census Bureau
reported recently.
Republicans blamed the stubborn poverty numbers on immigrants
holding down wages. Democrats blamed the Bush administration,
noting that incomes are lower and the poverty rate is
higher than when Bush took office. Democrats also noted
that the number of people without health insurance climbed
for the sixth straight year, reaching 46.6 million people
in 2005.
“I know what they say about putting lipstick on
a pig, but I don’t see how the Bush administration
can spin these numbers in their favor,” said Rep.
Charles Rangel, D-N.Y.
Bush’s budget chief said the new numbers show the
economy’s resilience following terrorist attacks
in 2001 and Hurricane Katrina a year ago.
“Unemployment is low, wages are rising and there
are more jobs in America today than at any other time
in history,” said Rob Portman, Bush’s budget
director. “While we still have challenges ahead,
our ability to bounce back is a testament to the strong
work ethic of the American people, the resiliency of our
economy, and pro-growth economic policies, including tax
relief.”
New Jersey had the highest median household income, at
$61,672. Mississippi had the lowest, at $32,938. Mississippi
also had the highest poverty rate, at 21.3 percent. New
Hampshire had the lowest, at 7.5 percent.
The official poverty level is used to decide eligibility
for federal health, housing, nutrition and child care
benefits. The poverty level differs by family size and
makeup. For example, the poverty level for a family of
four was $19,971 last year. For a family of two, it was
$12,755. About 12.6 percent of the population lived below
the poverty line in 2005. That’s down from 12.7
percent in 2004, but the change was not statistically
significant, census officials said.
The median household income - the point at which half
make more and half make less - was $46,326, a slight increase
from 2004, but still below the peak of $47,671 in 1999.
Meanwhile, it has been found that more teenagers are now
living in poverty than in recent years. States in the
Northeast and upper Midwest scored the best in terms of
children’s levels of income, with New Hampshire,
Vermont, Connecticut, Minnesota and Iowa at the top, while
Southern states did the worst, with Mississippi, Louisiana,
New Mexico, South Carolina and Tennessee at the bottom
of the pile.
More than 13 million children, about 18 percent, lived
in poverty in 2004, a slight increase from 17 percent
in 2000. One third of America’s children lived in
homes where none of the parents had full-time, year-round
jobs in 2004. That is a slight increase from 32 percent
in 2000.
Fat Dangers
An obesity pandemic threatens to overwhelm health systems
around the globe with illnesses such as diabetes and heart
disease, experts at an international conference have warned.
“This insidious, creeping pandemic of obesity is
now engulfing the entire world,” Paul Zimmet, chairman
of the meeting of more than 2,500 experts and health officials,
said in a speech opening the weeklong International Congress
on Obesity. “It’s as big a threat as global
warming and bird flu .”
The World Health Organization says more than 1 billion
adults are overweight and 300 million of them are obese,
putting them at much higher risk of diabetes, heart problems,
high blood pressure, stroke and some forms of cancer.
Zimmet, a diabetes expert at Australia’s Monash
University, said there are now more overweight people
in the world than the undernourished, who number about
600 million.
“We are not dealing with a scientific or medical
problem. We’re dealing with an enormous economic
problem that, it is already accepted, is going to overwhelm
every medical system in the world,” said Dr. Philip
James, the British chairman of the International Obesity
Task Force.
Among the most worrying problems are skyrocketing rates
of obesity among children, which make them much more prone
to chronic diseases as they grow older and could shave
years off their lives, experts said. The children in this
generation may be the first in history to die before their
parents because of health problems related to weight,
Kate Steinbeck, an expert in children’s health at
Sydney’s Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, said in a
statement.
Meanwhile, reports in this country have found that millions
of overweight baby boomers are on the fast track to becoming
disabled senior citizens, a possibility that could have
dire repercussions for them and for the nation’s
already overburdened nursing home system. Obesity will
have a big impact on increasing disability in this country
in the coming years unless the epidemic can be halted
and turned back,” says Richard Suzman of the National
Institute on Aging.
Public health officials have said for years that obesity
increases the risk of diseases such as type 2 diabetes,
heart disease, osteoarthritis and cancer. Now a growing
body of research suggests that being obese - 30 or more
pounds over a healthy weight - increases the chances of
becoming disabled at a younger age and unable to perform
tasks such as bathing or dressing.
The longer a person has been obese, the greater the wear
on joints and the probability of developing type 2 diabetes.
People who need joint replacements may have pain and disability
for years before the surgery and for months afterward
during recovery.
Experts are scrambling to head off the problem. The Obesity
Society and the American Society for Nutrition recently
called for obese older adults to lose weight to avoid
becoming disabled.
Main Streets…
A daylong forum in Catskill has been set to help business
owners, local leaders and municipal planners around the
region learn how to revitalize Main Streets in their communities.
The Sept. 18 Main Street Forum, sponsored by the Greene
County Planning and Economic Development, will offer a
half-dozen workshops with experts; a walking tour of downtown
Catskill, where a revitalization effort is under way;
and a networking reception at the BRIK Gallery. Admission
is free.
The forum will begin with registration at 8:30 a.m. at
the Washington Irving Senior Center, followed by a 9 a.m.
tour of Catskill’s Main Street, where dozens of
historic buildings have been restored. Norman Mintz, a
downtown revitalization expert known as “Dr. Downtown,”
will give a slide presentation on the community’s
role in the Main Street revitalization process. Additionally,
Robert Dadras of Dadras Architects will lead a session
on how a downtown plan is critical for success and explain
how a community can get started on developing such a plan.
There will also be a session, “Show Me the Money,”
that focuses on various funding sources available for
Main Street projects.
For more information or to register, call Greene County
Planning and Economic Development at (518) 719-3290 or
visit the Web site www.greeneeconomicdevelopment.com.
Golf Goes Down
Golf course openings fell from a peak of 398.5 in 2000
to 124.5 last year when measured in 18-hole equivalents,
the National Golf Foundation reports. During that time,
course closings soared from 23 to a record 93.5 last year.
When courses temporarily closed for renovation are included,
the USA had fewer golf courses open at the end of 2005
than a year earlier - the first year-to-year decline since
1945.
But that still leaves 16,052 courses nationwide.
“Golf courses aren’t generating the returns
people like to see,” says Mike Hughes, chief executive
of the National Golf Course Owners Association. “The
land has appreciated so much in value that it makes abundant
economic sense to turn the property over to other uses.”
Local governments often support the redevelopment because
it brings in more tax revenue than a golf course.
In The Myrtle Beach area, the nation’s top golf-tourist
destination, 17 courses out of 124 have closed. Hit hardest:
golf courses built in rural areas that since have been
surrounded by population growth. A golf course is a real
estate developer’s dream: about 150 acres of undeveloped
land.
Shorter golf courses and par-3 courses are being redeveloped
especially rapidly, the National Golf Foundation says.
Grass Fed?
If the government has its way, the grass-fed label could
be used to sell beef that didn’t roam the range
and ate more than just grass. The Agriculture Department
has proposed a standard for grass-fed meat that doesn’t
say animals need pasture and that broadly defines grass
to include things like leftovers from harvested crops.
Critics say the proposal is so loose that it would let
more conventional ranchers slap a grass-fed label on their
beef, too.
“In the eye of the consumer, grass-fed is tied to
open pasture-raised animals, not confinement or feedlot
animals,” said Patricia Whisnant, a Missouri rancher
who heads the American Grassfed Association. “In
the consumer’s eye, you’re going to lose the
integrity of what the term ‘grass-fed’ means.”
All beef cattle graze on grass at the beginning of their
lives. The difference generally is that grass-fed beef
herds graze in pastures, while conventional cattle spend
the last three or four months of their lives being fattened
with corn or other grains in feedlots.
People buy grass-fed beef for many reasons: They want
to avoid antibiotics commonly used in feedlots, they think
it’s healthier, or they like the idea of supporting
local farms and ranches.
Grass-fed beef is a leaner meat; fat tends to form around
the muscle. With conventional corn-fed beef, the fat streaks
the muscle in marble-like patterns.
Demand for grass-fed products is intense and producers
are responding. By Whisnant’s estimate, the number
of farms has grown from about 40 seven years ago to around
1,000 today.
“I’ve been an organic user for years, and
I am disenchanted,” Whisnant said. “My personal
opinion ... is that it’s lost meaning. To me, the
line in the sand is the confinement issue. A grass-fed
animal needs to be raised on pasture, and that’s
not just token access to pasture from his feedlot, but
he should get the majority of his ration from that growing
pasture.”
Giant Gnome
A 13.5-foot yard gnome off U.S. Route 209 in nearby Kerhonksen
should soon grace the pages of “Guinness World Records.”
The gnome, called Chomsky, will hold the record for the
world’s largest yard gnome. It stands sentry over
Gnome on the Grange, a mini-golf course at Kelder’s
Farm.
The gnome was the brainchild of Maria Reidelbach, who
also built the mini-golf course on Kelder’s Farm.
The record-setting gnome is actually Chomsky II, Reidelbach
explains. The original Chomsky was built in 2003, but
was made out of the wrong material to be qualified for
the world record.
Guinness said that for Chomsky to be record-setting, he
would have to be built out of the same materials as other
yard gnomes: cement. Reidelbach said she was committed
to making the world’s biggest gnome and enlisted
artist Ken Hutchinson to craft Chomsky II out of cement,
straw and chicken wire.
Guinness did not have a previous record in this category.
As part of the rules of Guinness, Reidelbach assembled
a board of “local luminaries” that included
Ulster County Legislator Rich Parete, Rochester Town Supervisor
Pamela Duke and Mark Brown, leader of a local country-rock
band, to witness the event.
2004 Revisited
With paper ballots from the 2004 presidential election
in Ohio scheduled to be destroyed this month, the secretary
of state in Columbus, under pressure from critics, has
moved to delay the destruction at least for several months.
Since the election, questions have been raised about how
votes were tallied in Ohio, a battleground state that
helped deliver the election to President Bush over Senator
John Kerry. The critics, including an independent candidate
for governor and a team of statisticians and lawyers,
say preliminary results from their ballot inspections
show signs of more widespread irregularities than previously
known. The critics say the ballots should be saved pending
an investigation. They also say the secretary of state’s
proposal to delay the destruction does not go far enough,
and they intend to sue to preserve the ballots.
In Florida in 2003, historians and lawyers persuaded state
officials not to destroy the ballots in the 2000 presidential
election, and those ballots are stored at the state archive.
Lawyers for J. Kenneth Blackwell, the Ohio secretary of
state, said although he did not have the authority to
preserve the ballots, Mr. Blackwell would issue an order
in a day or two that delays the destruction and that reminds
local elections officials that they have to consult the
public records commissions in each county. Federal law
permits, but does not require, destroying paper ballots
from federal elections 22 months after Election Day.
The critics say their sole interest in the question is
to improve the voting system.
“This is not about Mr. Kerry or Mr. Bush or who
should be president,’’ said Bill Goodman,
legal director of the Center for Constitutional Rights,
a New York group that is part of the lawsuit. “This
is about figuring out what is not working in our election
system and ensuring that every cast vote counts.
“There is a gap between the numbers provided in
the local level records, which until recently no one has
been allowed to see, and the official final tallies that
were publicly released after this election, and we want
to figure out why that gap is there.”
After eight months inspecting 35,000 ballots from 75 rural
and urban precincts, the critics say that they have found
many with signs of tampering and that in some precincts
the number of voters differs significantly from the certified
results. The investigation has not inspected all 5.6 million
ballots in the election because the critics were not given
access to them until January. That followed an agreement
by the League of Women Voters, a plaintiff in another
election suit against the state, that it was not contesting
the 2004 results, Mr. Goodman said.
The new suit, to be filed in Federal District Court in
Columbus, would be argued on civil rights grounds, saying
the state deprived voters of equal treatment.
Weather Origins
U.S. weather experts have descended on a tiny village
in Senegal to try to understand how hurricanes that slam
into the southeastern United States and the Caribbean
are formed in West Africa before they go bowling across
the Atlantic. The study, backed by U.S. space agency NASA,
could help forecasters better predict devastating hurricanes
like Katrina , which formed over Africa and killed around
1,500 people when it rammed into New Orleans a year ago
in one of the worst natural disasters in American history.
More than 80 percent of the systems that hit the United
States have their origins in tropical disturbances leaving
Africa. But 95 percent of the storms that start there
fizzle over the Atlantic.
“If we can capture the atmospheric conditions of
the storm, the storm structure, how they evolve over the
African continent and just off the coast, our objective
is to distinguish between those that stay together and
those that dissipate,” said a spokesman for the
study, which has set up three radars — one in landlocked
Niger’s capital Niamey, the one in Kawsara on the
Senegalese coast, and one on the Cape Verde Islands —
and is also flying planes into the center of the depressions.
The data they provide will enable scientists for the first
time to map more fully the atmospheric conditions as Atlantic
hurricanes are born and through their life cycle.
Previous attempts to understand the phenomenon have relied
on satellite data, which can show what is happening on
top of clouds but not inside them. Last time a similar
project was carried out was in 1974, with hugely inferior
technology.
“No one has a good sense of which system is going
to form, if it’s going to intensify, if it’s
going to weaken and one of the problems is Saharan dust,”
said one of the study’s leading scientists who has
studied West African weather for more than two decades.
“We think that Saharan dust actually inhibits the
formation of cyclones but this is the first time we can
fly inside them and see how much dust is there.”
Suicide On Rise
More people kill themselves each year than die from wars
and murders combined, but most suicides could be prevented,
two international experts on suicide said recently.
Some 20 million to 60 million try to kill themselves each
year, but only about a million of them succeed, said a
mental health official at the World Health Organization
in Geneva.
The ones who do end their lives "are tragic situations
where help could have been provided," said the International
Association for Suicide Prevention in Gondrin, France.
Suicide rates could be reduced if countries would limit
access to pesticides, guns and medication and do a better
job of treating people with depression, alcoholism and
schizophrenia, both organizations agreed.
About a third of all suicides around the world are caused
by pesticides. Dentists, veterinarians and doctors are
particularly at risk for suicide -- not because of their
high-stress professions but because they have access to
lethal chemicals and know how to handle them. Those who
lose a job abruptly are more likely to kill themselves
than people living in poor social conditions for long
periods, he said.
Also, people living in countries where suicide is illegal
like Singapore, Lebanon and India are less likely to seek
help if they have suicidal thoughts, for fear the government
may punish them.
Passport Needs
The time to start packing for that winter trip to the
Caribbean may be now -- you are going to need a passport.
Congress and the Department of Homeland Security are tightening
border procedures for both U.S. citizens and foreign travelers
entering the U.S. By Jan. 8, passports will be required
for most everyone entering the U.S. from the Caribbean,
Canada and Mexico through airports and seaports, instead
of just a birth certificate and driver's license. Land
borders will adopt the same requirement Jan. 1, 2008.
The travel industry and several border-state governors
and senators have been pushing for a delay in the new
rules, fearing confusion and long delays for travelers
that could hurt the cruise industry in particular. Only
25% of Americans have passports, and many could be left
high and dry if they don't get one before they head off
to an island cruise. As requirements tighten, more people
have been applying. Last year, the State Department issued
10.1 million passports, up 15% from 2004. This year is
on pace for about a 16% increase.
One pitfall for travelers to watch out for: All children,
including babies, will need passports. Since July 2001,
the government has required both parents to apply together
for a child's passport, if the child is 14 or under. This
is to make sure one parent isn't trying to take a child
out of the country without the other's permission. It
can be a hassle for single parents who have to prove they
have sole authority or need to get notarized consent from
the other parent.
Another change: Last month, the State Department began
issuing electronic passports with a computer chip in the
rear cover that contains all the information found on
the data page of the passport, such as name, date of birth,
passport number and a photograph. For security protection,
the e-passports have a metallic material in the front
cover and the data are encrypted to prevent eavesdropping.
(People with older-style passports don't need to trade
theirs in.)
Even if travelers are ready, travel experts say the government
may not be well-prepared, and the result of the heightened
security could be long lines at airports and seaports.
The Travel Industry Association, a lobbying group for
cruise lines, tour companies, resorts and airlines, says
it supports the move to require better documentation,
but it fears the government won't have the staff, equipment
and procedures in place needed to process people quickly.
The government says it is going ahead with the change
starting Jan. 8. The deadline was pushed back a week from
the first day of the year so it wouldn't kick in during
holiday travels. That has been the only delay granted
so far.
Despite initial grumbling that the process was intrusive
and unwarranted and would curb travel to the U.S., international
travel has been increasing and officials say processing
at airports has actually sped up because inspectors have
assurance of a person's identity when the green light
on the finger scanner goes on. The success has led other
nations in Europe and Asia to begin adopting similar measures.
The latest proposed changes may be harder to implement
for screening the 400 million people who cross into the
U.S. every year, raising fears of long lines at airports,
sea ports and roadway crossings.
The State Department and Homeland Security say passport
books take too long to process at high-volume land-border
checkpoints, so they are developing a "passport card"
that will have your information embedded electronically
and will communicate wirelessly with Immigration and Customs
Enforcement computers, much like a toll tag on the highway.
Homeland Security also has proposed forcing the 11 million
permanent legal residents of the U.S. -- green-card holders
-- to cross border checkpoints with foreign nationals,
not U.S. citizens. The change could take effect next year.
Medicare Cuts...
The Bush administration and Republican-led Congress are
headed for a political confrontation with an influential
constituency: the 700,000 doctors who treat seniors in
the Medicare program and are frantically trying to stave
off a planned cut in their fees.
The American Medical Assn. said recentlyy that doctors
may stop taking seniors as new patients — or even
drop out of the program — if the cuts go through.
It has launched a nationwide blitz to persuade Congress
to rescind a 5.1% cut planned for next year, insisting
that lawmakers act before they adjourn in October to campaign
for reelection.
The reduction for 2007 is part of a planned series of
cuts that would reduce fees paid to physicians by 40%
over the next nine years. In recent years, Congress has
been willing to postpone the cuts. Now, frustration is
mounting at the AMA because that no longer seems to be
the case.